Skip to main content
. 2023 Dec 12;18(12):e0289249. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0289249

Table 1. Results of the Mann-Kendall Test for Trend for 48 time-series observations by pathogen and initial inoculum level.

         Mann-Kendall Test Values 
Pathogen Lot Replicate n S p-value conclusion
Campylobacter (43 to 162 CFU/mL initial inoculum) A 1 6 -10 0.035
    2 6 -12 0.013
  B 1 6 -12 0.013
    2 6 -9 0.036
  C 1 6 -10 0.035
    2 6 -12 0.013
Campylobacter (600 to 1,100 CFU/mL initial inoculum) A 1 6 -12 0.013
    2 6 -12 0.013
  B 1 6 -12 0.018
    2 6 -8 0.090 NT
  C 1 6 -12 0.018
    2 6 -14 0.006
L. monocytogenes (26 to 41 CFU/mL initial inoculum) A 1 6 11 0.030 +
    2 6 10 0.043 +
  B 1 6 11 0.030 +
    2 6 11 0.030 +
  C 1 6 9 0.066 NT
    2 6 9 0.066 NT
L. monocytogenes (3,000 to 7,900 CFU/mL initial inoculum) A 1 6 13 0.012 +
    2 6 9 0.066 NT
  B 1 6 13 0.012 +
    2 6 15 0.004 +
  C 1 6 13 0.012 +
    2 6 9 0.066 NT
E. coli O157:H7 (22 to 46 CFU/mL initial inoculum) A 1 6 -3 0.354 NT
    2 6 -1 0.500 NT
  B 1 6 -3 0.354 NT
    2 6 -3 0.354 NT
  C 1 6 -8 0.090 NT
    2 6 -4 0.283 NT
E. coli O157:H7 (6,700 to 8,300 CFU/mL initial inoculum) A 1 6 -7 0.130 NT
    2 6 -5 0.226 NT
  B 1 6 -5 0.226 NT
    2 6 -1 0.500 NT
  C 1 6 -9 0.066 NT
    2 6 -3 0.354 NT
Salmonella (56 to 86 CFU/mL initial inoculum) A 1 6 9 0.066 NT
    2 6 -3 0.354 NT
  B 1 6 -9 0.066 NT
    2 6 1 0.500 NT
  C 1 6 -11 0.030
    2 6 -12 0.018
Salmonella (3,700 to 6,200 CFU/mL initial inoculum) A 1 6 -11 0.030
    2 6 -7 0.130 NT
  B 1 6 -12 0.018
    2 6 -15 0.004
  C 1 6 -9 0.066 NT
    2 6 -15 0.004

Notes: Lot = bottle of raw milk; A, B, and C were bottles from the same day of production; Replicate = duplicate analyses from each lot of raw milk; n = number of observations in each time series; S = Mann-Kendall test statistic; p-values less than 0.05 shown in bold font indicating a statistically significant increasing or decreasing trend conclusion; Down arrows = Evidence of a statistically significant decreasing trend; + = Evidence of a statistically significant increasing trend; NT = no trend observed.