Skip to main content
. 2023 Dec 14;13:22247. doi: 10.1038/s41598-023-46158-0

Table 5.

Average values of higher and lower heating values and energy density of the reference and torrefied sludges.

Sludges Temperature Higher heating values (MJ kg−1) Lower heating values (MJ kg−1) Energy density (MJ kg−1)
Time Time Time
20′ 40′ 20′ 40′ 20′ 40′ 20′ 40′ 20′
PS 260 °C 17.5 Bc 17.6 Bc 17.9 Ac 15.3 Cc 15.8 Bc 16.4 Ac 2.53 Aa* 2.37 Bb 2.24 Cc
290 °C 17.7 Cb 18.1 Bb 19.7 Ab 16.0 Cb 16.4 Bb 18.1 Ab 2.55 Aa* 2.41 Bb 2.55 Aa*
320 °C 18.1 Ca 19.5 Ba 25.5 Aa 16.4 Ca 17.8 Ba 24.0 Aa 2.44 Bb 2.58 Aa* 2.48 Bb
Reference 17.2 13.7 2.55
SS 260 °C 17.6 Ba 17.5 Bb 17.7 Ac 15.8 Cab 16.0 Bb 16.5 Ac 9.52 Ba 9.51 Bb 9.84 Ac
290 °C 17.4 Cb 17.7 Ba 18.0 Ab 15.7 Cb 16.4 Ba 16.8 Ab 9.34 Ca 9.62 Ba 9.95 Ab
320 °C 17.4 Cab 17.8 Ba 18.6 Aa 15.8 Ca 16.4 Ba 17.5 Aa 9.32 Ca 9.61 Ba 10.27 Aa
Reference 17.2 13.8 8.15
MIX 260 °C 17.1 Cb 17.3 Bc 17.6 Ac 15.3 Cc 16.0 Bc 16.2 Ac 2.96 Bb* 3.09 Ac 2.95 Bc*
290 °C 17.1 Cbc* 17.7 Bb 18.2 Ab 15.5 Cb 16.1 Bb 16.8 Ab 2.97 Cb 3.16 Bb 3.30 Aa
320 °C 17.4 Ca 18.2 Ba 20.1 Aa 15.8 Ca 16.6 Ba 18.8 Aa 3.06 Ba 3.29 Aa 3.22 Ab
Reference 17.0 13.4 2.93

Averages followed by the same capital letter between lines (time and properties) and lowercase between columns (temperature and sludge) do not differ, at 5% significance, by the Tukey test, for each type of sludge. *Do not differ from the reference, at 5% significance, by the Dunnet test, for each type of sludge.

PS—primary sludge, SS—secondary sludge, MIX—primary and secondary sludge.