Study |
Treatment Groups |
Results |
Conclusions |
Monteiro et al. [26] |
4% HQ 0.75% KA and 2.5% Vitamin C |
Decrease in MASI score in weeks 0-12, significant change from weeks 0-4 with 4% HQ treatment Decrease in MASI score in weeks 0-12, no significant change from weeks 0-4 with 0.75% KA treatment |
The results of treatment with hydroquinone have an earlier onset than treatment with KA |
Owolabi et al. [28] |
Group A, control Group B, 2% HQ Group C, 2% KA Group D, 4% HQ Group E, 4% KA Group F, 2% HQ and 2% KA Group G, 4% HQ and 4% KA Group H, 4% HQ, 4% KA, and aloe vera |
Groups B and D showed greater disruption of the stratum corneum Groups F, G, and H showed less disruption of the stratum corneum Groups A, C, and E did not cause observable disruption to the stratum corneum |
Hydroquinone may cause greater disruption of the stratum corneum, while KA and aloe vera may ameliorate these effects |
Marpaung et al. [29] |
3% TA, 4% HQ |
More significant decrease in MASI score and MI in 3% TA group |
3% TA cream and 4% hydroquinone cream are effective in decreasing MASI score and MI |
Arrowitz et al. [30] |
0.2% Thiamidol-side vs. untreated side of face 0.2% Thiamidol-side vs. 2.0% HQ-side |
Significant decrease in MASI score in thiamidol-treated side vs. untreated Decrease in MASI scores in both treated sides, more significant improvement in thiamidol-treated side, some worsening noted in HQ-treated sides |
0.2% Thiamidol is more effective in the treatment of epidermal melasma than 2.0% hydroquinone |