Skip to main content
. 2023 Dec 21;24:383. doi: 10.1186/s12882-023-03406-9

Table 12.

Excerpt 11 Discussion of age in relation to kidney donors

Turn Speaker Talk
367. CKD-P7 Is it better to get a kidney from a young person or an older person?
368. Doc2: Young.
369. CKD-P7 : Is it?
370. Doc2: Better for you.
371. CKD-P7 : Oh. I was thinking maybe [John(husband)] can give me one of his. My husband. [Laughs]
372. Doc2: Yeah, sure, if he wants to.
373. CKD-P7 : But he’s old.
374. Doc2: How old is he?
375. CKD-P7 : He’s three years older than me, four years older than me.
376. Doc2: That’s okay. A living kidney, if you’re considering, do I want it from him, he, as you say, is old, compared to waiting for a deceased donor, a living kidney is almost always better than one from someone who’s died.
377. CKD-P7 : Okay.
378. Doc2: Because it’s taken out from them in a controlled fashion, and then it’s put straight into you.
379. CKD-P7 : Yep.
380 omitted
381. CKD-P7 : What about the risk of rejection, [John(husband)] or [Charlie(son)], it would be better for me to adapt? Because [Charlie(son)] is like…
382. DSS02: Well, [Charlie(son)] is likely to be a better match.
383. Patient N: Better match.
384. Doc2: Yeah. But we don’t yet know whether you have any antibodies. You may from pregnancy.
385. CKD-P7 : Mm.
386. Doc2: So we don’t know how hard that side of things would be. [Charlie(son)]’s kidney is likely to be better for you than your husband’s because he’s going to be younger.
387. CKD-P7 : Mm.
388. Doc2: But I think either would be pretty good.
389. CKD-P7 : Okay, because I’m just thinking, leave the young ones alone. We can grow old together with one kidney each. [Laughs]
390. Doc2: It’s a reasonable way to think. And also, if that kidney didn’t work out…
391. CKD-P7 : Then I’ve still got [Charlie(son)]. [Laughs]
392. Doc2: You’ve still got [Charlie(son)] as a backup.
393. CKD-P7 : [Laughs]
394. Doc2: It’s tough, isn’t it?