Skip to main content
. 2023 Dec 7;23(24):9672. doi: 10.3390/s23249672

Table 8.

Dynamic Scenario 1—Perpendicular movement.

Collisions Number Safety Score (%) Navigation Time (s) Path Length (m) Collisions Number Safety Score (%) Navigation Time (s) Path Length (m)
vobs=0.2m/s 4 Dynamic Obstacles 8 Dynamic Obstacles
DWA 0.7 7.41 80.78 27.10 2.8 18.01 85.90 27.09
TEB 0.3 5.87 77.70 29.13 0.3 5.87 91.00 32.27
CADRL 0.9 25.30 90.16 36.85 1.2 24.03 90.40 42.90
SAC 1.4 23.44 78.41 26.89 1.5 25.44 90.14 28.82
vobs=0.3m/s 4 Dynamic Obstacles 8 Dynamic Obstacles
DWA 2.1 9.30 79.72 26.34 2.8 21.61 83.02 25.90
TEB 0.5 7.33 81.11 30.08 1.4 15.33 106.24 37.39
CADRL 1.4 22.60 87.27 42.98 1.8 29.65 90.25 43.05
SAC 2.0 22.97 73.13 26.06 3.9 35.00 79.11 27.30
vobs=0.4m/s 4 Dynamic Obstacles 8 Dynamic Obstacles
DWA 1.3 9.45 77.06 26.34 2.5 23.97 89.43 27.98
TEB 0.9 6.94 82.93 30.48 2.2 14.59 107.20 36.93
CADRL 2.0 24.71 90.69 43.02 1.9 25.08 92.20 43.25
SAC 1.7 13.68 73.11 26.04 3.5 33.13 76.80 26.80