Skip to main content
. 2023 Dec 22;13(12):e070677. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2022-070677

Table 1.

Characteristics of included studies

Study Country Population No of participants Methods Ref
Qualitative
Birhanu 2018 Ethiopia Pregnant women and healthcare providers 20 women, 22 healthcare providers Phenomology 19
Martin 2017a Kenya Pregnant women and healthcare providers 22 women, 20 healthcare providers Phenomology 38
Martin 2018 Kenya Healthcare providers, pregnant women, adherence partners 7 healthcare providers, 32 pregnant women, 20 adherence partners Phenomology 39
Vestering 2019 Netherlands Healthcare providers and pregnant women 8 healthcare providers, 25 women Phenomology 18
Mixed methods
Kachwaha 2022 India Healthcare providers, supervisors and facility staffs ~500 healthcare providers and supervisors, and 20 block level staffs Mixed methods 42
Martin 2017b and Omatoyo 2018a Kenya and Ethiopia Pregnant women 85 pregnant women, 50 in Ethiopia, 38 in Kenya Trials of improved practices 40 41
Quantitative
Baxter 2014 Bangladesh Pregnant women 132 Modified discrete-choice trial 30
Bora 2022 India Pregnant women 3 097 274 Cross-sectional study 27
Ghosh-Jareth 2015 India Pregnant women and recently delivered women 184 pregnant women and 160 recently delivered women Cross-sectional study 29
Liu 2019 China Women aged from 16 to 49 years who were pregnant between 2010 and 2013 and had specific pregnancy outcomes before the survey 30 027 Cross-sectional study 36
Martin 2017c and Omotayo 2018b Kenya Pregnant women 990 pregnant women and 16 facilities Process evaluation study adopting programme impact pathway 28 33
Nguyen 2017 Bangladesh Pregnant women and recently delivered women 600 pregnant women and 2000 recently delivered women Cross-sectional household surveys 34
Nguyen 2018 Bangladesh Women and husbands 1000 women and 70% of their husbands Cluster randomised control trial with cross-sectional household surveys 35
Nguyen 2019 India Pregnant women and recently delivered women 667 pregnant women and 1835 recently delivered women Cross-sectional household surveys 32
Shakya Shrestha 2020 Nepal Pregnant women 191 Cross-sectional study 37
Thapa 2016 Nepal Pregnant and postpartum women, health facilities, female community health volunteers 1240 Prospective collection and secondary analysis of monitoring data captured by the MOHP 31