Table 2.
Study | Characteristics | Procedure/results | Conclusion |
---|---|---|---|
Garcia (2021) 6 | Aim To analyze the trends and outcomes of RIRS (retrograde intrarenal surgery) for the treatment of urolithiasis in anomalous kidneys in a large international multicenter series. Study Retrospective-multicentric |
Patients 414, males = 227, females = 137 HSK = 119, EK = 102, MRK = 69, Diverticular calculus = 50 Stone characteristics Size Avg. 13.9 mm (±6) Procedure In 249 cases (60.14%), a disposable scope was used, and a reusable scope in 165 (39.85%) cases A preoperative stent was reported in 46.6% UAS was used in 90% of cases Holmium: Yttrium-almuniuim-garnet laser was used in 391 (94.4%) patients and a thulium fiber laser in 23 (5.6%) The mean operative time was 65.3 min Post-op stenting was performed in 392 (94.7%) patients Our series had a single-stage SFR of 79.2% Complications Hematuria (10.9%), upper urinary tract perforation, or a ureteral injury 1.9% and 1.7%, respectively Surgery abandonment in 4.3% |
RIRS in patients with anomalous kidneys is a safe and effective treatment with an acceptable complication rate in experienced hands. The SFR is expected to be high when careful case selection is made and when patients are treated in high-volume centers with experienced surgeons |
Lavan (2019) 7 | Aim Role of ureteroscopy in the management of stones in anomalous kidneys Study Systemic review 14 Studies, 13 retrospectives, 1 prospective |
Patients 413 (30.5) had a previous endourological procedure HSK = 204, EK = 117, MRK = 86, CFRE = 2, Others = 4 Stone characteristics Size Avg. 16 mm Stone location (lower pole 34.6%, pelvic 31%, multiple locations 18.9%) Procedure Ureteroscopies only Flexible URS was used in 90% of cases A preoperative stent was reported in 26.4% UAS was reported in 11 studies Holmium laser was used in 12 out of 13 studies The mean operative time was 61.3 min (range: 14–185 min) Post-op stenting was done in all patients in 6 studies in others it was variable (46.2–84%) The initial and final SFR was 76.6% (n = 322) and 82.3% (n = 340), respectively Overall, 71 (17.2%) Complications Complications were reported of which 61 (14.8%) were Clavien–Dindo ⩽ II, and 10 (2.4%) were Clavien–Dindo ⩾ III |
Ureteroscopy in patients with anomalous kidneys can be technically challenging, advancements in endourological techniques have made it a safe and effective procedure. In these patients, the stone-free rates are good with a low risk of major complications |
Ugurlu (2014) 8 | Aim Ureteroscopy in the management of anomalous kidney stones Study Retrospective |
Patients 25 (17 males, 8 females) Lumbar ectopic: 7, pelvic ectopic: 6, HSK: 3, mal-rotated kidney: 4, CFRE: 1, Others: 4 Stone characteristics Size 194.4 mm2 Location (lower calyx 14, middle calyx 4, upper calyx 7, pelvis 7) Procedure RIRS with holmium laser Complications Renal colic/urosepsis/pyelonephritis (1 each case) |
F-URS with holmium laser lithotripsy is a very effective therapy for most stones in anomalous kidneys due to its less invasive nature, repeatable applicability, and acceptable complication rates |
CFRE, crossed fused renal ectopia; EK, ectopic kidney; ESWL, extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy; HSK, horseshoe kidneys; MRK, Mal-rotated kidneys; RIRS, retrograde intra-renal surgery; UAS, ureteral access sheath; URS, ureterorenoscopy.