Skip to main content
. 2023 Dec 24;15:17562872231217797. doi: 10.1177/17562872231217797

Table 3.

PCNL in anomalous kidney stone management.

Study Characteristics Procedure/results Conclusion
Prakash (2017) 10 Aim
 PCNL in anomalous kidneys
Study
 Retrospective
Patients
 Patients 86
 Male/female: 58/28
 Bifid system: 40
 HSK: 20, MRK: 8, PK: 8, CFRE: 4, crossed ectopia: 6
Stone characteristics
 Size: 4.4 cm ± 1.6
 Location: pure pelvic 50, calyceal 26, complex 15
Procedure
 PCNL
Complications Clavien–Dindo
 Grade 1–16, Grade 2–15, Grade 3–0, Grade 4–3
PCNL in the anomalous kidney is a safe and feasible procedure like a normally located kidney but requires careful preoperative planning and one has to be vigilant for all possible intraoperative and postoperative complications
Gupta (2009) 9 Aim
 PCNL in anomalous kidneys
Study
 Retrospective
Patients
 Patients 46 (52 renal units)
 Male/female: 28/18
 HSK: 31, MRK: 7, PK: 4, CFRE: 4
Stone characteristics
 Size: 2.4 cm, Avg.
 Location: pure pelvic 26, pelvicalyceal 14, calyceal 12
Procedure
 PCNL/Relook PCNL in 7
Complications
 Minimal
PCNL is technically very challenging in anomalous kidneys because the abnormal pelvicalyceal system results in difficulty in access.
We recommend PCNL as the modality of choice for anomalous kidneys with larger stones (2 cm) or ESWL refractory stones. Laparoscopic assistance improves the safety of PCNL in pelvic ectopic kidneys and should be used for such conditions

CFRE, crossed fused renal ectopia; HSK, horseshoe kidneys; MRK, Mal-rotated kidneys; PCNL, percutaneous nephrolithotomy; PK, pelvic kidney.