Table 1.
Social demographic characteristics of Chatbot users and non-users enrolled from the selected centers in District Korangi, Sindh between March 9 and August 20, 2020.
| Total (n = 2,202) | Chatbot Users (n = 210) | Non Chatbot Users (n = 1,992) | % Difference | 95 % CI | P Value | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Information on Child | n | % | n | % | n | % | ||||
| Females | 1,095 | 49∙7 | 110 | 52∙4 | 985 | 49∙4 | 3∙0 | −4∙10 | 10∙10 | 0∙41 |
| Enrollment age (months) | ||||||||||
| 0–1 | 901 | 40∙9 | 106 | 50∙5 | 795 | 39∙9 | 10∙6 | 3∙50 | 17∙70 | 0∙0030 |
| 2–3 | 503 | 22∙8 | 51 | 24∙3 | 452 | 22∙7 | 1∙6 | −4∙48 | 7∙68 | 0∙60 |
| 4–6 | 205 | 9∙3 | 17 | 8∙1 | 188 | 9∙4 | −1∙3 | −5∙21 | 2∙61 | 0∙54 |
| 7–12 | 565 | 25∙7 | 35 | 16∙7 | 530 | 26∙6 | −9∙9 | −15∙30 | −4∙50 | 0∙0018 |
| 12 – 24 | 28 | 1∙3 | 1 | 0∙5 | 27 | 1∙4 | −0∙9 | −1∙98 | 1∙84 | 0∙28 |
| Enrollment Vaccine | ||||||||||
| BCG/ OPV 0 | 670 | 30∙4 | 74 | 35∙2 | 596 | 29∙9 | 5∙3 | −1∙46 | 12∙06 | 0∙11 |
| Penta 1/ OPV 1/ PCV 1 | 399 | 18∙1 | 46 | 21∙9 | 353 | 17∙7 | 4∙2 | −1∙64 | 10∙04 | 0∙13 |
| Penta 2/ OPV 2/ PCV 2 | 298 | 13∙5 | 30 | 14∙3 | 268 | 13∙4 | 0∙9 | −4∙06 | 5∙87 | 0∙72 |
| Penta 3/ OPV 3/ PCV 3 | 292 | 13∙3 | 27 | 12∙9 | 265 | 13∙3 | −0∙4 | −5∙17 | 4∙37 | 0∙87 |
| Measles 1 | 543 | 24∙7 | 33 | 15∙7 | 510 | 25∙6 | −9∙9 | −15∙18 | −4∙62 | 0∙0015 |
| Respondent’s relationship with child | ||||||||||
| Mother | 1,484 | 67∙4 | 129 | 61∙4 | 1,355 | 68∙0 | −6∙6 | −13∙50 | 0∙30 | 0∙052 |
| Father | 718 | 32∙6 | 81 | 38∙6 | 637 | 32∙0 | 6∙6 | −3∙00 | 13∙50 | 0∙052 |
| Parent’s Education (years) | ||||||||||
| Father | ||||||||||
| 0 | 98 | 4∙5 | 8 | 3∙8 | 90 | 4∙5 | −0∙7 | −3∙44 | 2∙04 | 0∙64 |
| 1–5 | 88 | 4∙0 | 5 | 2∙4 | 83 | 4∙2 | −1∙8 | −4∙04 | 0∙44 | 0∙21 |
| 6–10 | 1,062 | 48∙4 | 94 | 45∙0 | 968 | 48∙7 | −3∙7 | −10∙78 | 3∙38 | 0∙31 |
| 11–12 | 532 | 24∙2 | 62 | 29∙7 | 470 | 23∙6 | 6∙1 | −0∙36 | 12∙56 | 0∙050 |
| >12 | 416 | 18∙9 | 40 | 19∙1 | 376 | 18∙9 | 0∙2 | −5∙39 | 5∙79 | 0∙94 |
| Mother | ||||||||||
| 0 | 98 | 4∙5 | 7 | 3∙4 | 91 | 4∙6 | −1∙2 | −3∙82 | 1∙42 | 0∙42 |
| 1–5 | 87 | 4∙0 | 2 | 1∙0 | 85 | 4∙3 | −3∙3 | −4∙91 | −1∙69 | 0∙020 |
| 6–10 | 1,086 | 49∙4 | 95 | 45∙4 | 991 | 49∙9 | −4∙5 | −11∙58 | 2∙58 | 0∙23 |
| 11–12 | 578 | 26∙3 | 57 | 27∙3 | 521 | 26∙2 | 1∙1 | −5∙22 | 7∙43 | 0∙73 |
| >12 | 347 | 15∙8 | 48 | 23∙0 | 299 | 15∙0 | 8∙0 | 2∙10 | 13∙90 | 0∙0025 |
| Parent’s Occupation | ||||||||||
| Father | ||||||||||
| Private job | 1,744 | 79∙2 | 172 | 81∙9 | 1,572 | 78∙9 | 3∙0 | −2∙50 | 8∙50 | 0∙31 |
| Skilled Labor | 111 | 5∙0 | 8 | 3∙8 | 103 | 5∙2 | −1∙4 | −4∙16 | 1∙36 | 0∙38 |
| Government job | 109 | 5∙0 | 11 | 5∙2 | 98 | 4∙9 | 0∙3 | −2∙84 | 3∙45 | 0∙85 |
| Professional |
53 |
2∙4 |
6 |
2∙9 |
47 |
2∙4 |
0∙5 |
−1∙87 |
2∙87 |
0∙66 |
| Manual Labour |
137 |
6∙2 |
9 |
4∙3 |
128 |
6∙4 |
−2∙1 |
−5∙05 |
0∙85 |
0∙23 |
| Unemployed |
22 |
1∙0 |
2 |
1∙0 |
20 |
1∙0 |
0 |
−1∙41 |
1∙41 |
1∙0 |
| Other |
26 |
1∙2 |
2 |
1∙0 |
24 |
1∙2 |
−0∙2 |
−1∙63 |
1∙23 |
0∙80 |
| Mother | ||||||||||
| Housewife | 2,192 | 99∙6 | 209 | 99∙5 | 1,983 | 99∙6 | −0∙1 | −1∙09 | 0∙89 | 0∙83 |
| Employed | 10 | 0∙4 | 1 | 0∙5 | 9 | 0∙4 | 0∙1 | −0∙89 | 1∙09 | 0∙83 |
| Median | IQR | Median | IQR | Median | IQR | Median Difference | ||||
| Enrollment age for child | 2∙73 | 7∙67 | 1∙86 | 3∙19 | 2∙83 | 7∙62 | 0∙97 | −1∙53 | −0∙37 | 0∙001 |
| Median Father’s educations | 10 | 2 | 10 | 2 | 10 | 2 | 0∙0 | −0∙95 | 0∙95 | 1∙0 |
| Median Mother’s education | 10 | 2 | 12 | 2 | 10 | 2 | 2∙0 | 1∙91 | 2∙09 | <0∙001 |