Skip to main content
. 2023 Dec 19;14:1292673. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2023.1292673

TABLE 1.

Risk-of-bias analysis of studies included in the systematic review examining the effects of exercise interventions on the gut microbiome in humans.

Study Selection of participants free from bias Study with >80% follow up a Standard/valid/reliable data collection procedures QCC b , c rating
Calabrese et al. (2022) Yes No Yes
Cheng et al. (2022) Yes No Yes
Cronin et al. (2018) Yes Yes Yes +
Cronin et al. (2019) Yes No Yes
Dupuit et al. (2022) Yes No Yes
Kern et al. (2020) Yes No Yes
Liu et al. (2020) Yes Yes Yes
Mahdieh et al. (2021) Yes Yes Yes +
Moitinho-Silva et al. (2021) Yes Yes Yes
Mokhtarzade et al. (2021) Yes Yes Yes +
Morita et al. (2019) No Yes Yes
Motiani et al. (2020) Yes No Yes +
Resende et al. (2021) Yes Yes Yes +
Sun et al. (2022) Yes No Yes
Taniguchi et al. (2018) Yes Yes Yes +
Torquati et al. (2022) Yes d No Yes
Warbeck et al. (2021) Yes No Yes
Wei et al. (2022) Yes No Yes
Zhong et al. (2020) Yes Yes Yes +
a

Follow-up here takes into account participant attrition or participants included in analysis.

b

QCC, quality criteria checklist.

c

QCC, rating: +, report has clearly addressed issues of inclusion/exclusion, bias, generalizability, and data collection and analysis; ∅, report is neither exceptionally strong nor exceptionally weak.

d

Original study.