Skip to main content
. 2023 Dec 8;31(2):2377–2393. doi: 10.1007/s11356-023-31354-2

Table 2.

Descriptive statistics for microbiological and physicochemical parameters before and after EM application in the Turawa reservoir

Statistics Period Parameter (unit)
HBN22 (CFU∙mL−1) HBN36 (CFU∙mL−1) CBN (CFU∙mL−1) FCBN (CFU∙mL−1) FEN (CFU∙mL−1) pH (-) EC (µS∙cm−1) TN (mg∙L−1) NO3–N (mg∙L−1) PO4–P (mg∙L−1) TP (mg∙L−1) DO (mg∙L−1) BOD5 (mg∙L−1) COD (mg∙L−1)
Min Before EM 180 50 23 15 3 6.70 202 1.31 0.060 0.000 0.03 0.00 0.70 1.20
After EM 2100 1500 75 75 9 6.88 203 1.48 0.110 0.009 0.09 7.30 1.70 6.70
Max Before EM 985,000 755,000 2420 2420 460 9.90 491 12.30 4.210 0.390 11.50 13.10 54.00 320.10
After EM 110,000 71,000 2420 2420 460 10.30 507 12.09 1.710 0.100 1.07 12.30 9.80 30.80
Std. deviation Before EM 192,694 181,379 920 893 86 0.65 39 2.04 0.824 0.052 1.52 2.10 6.32 38.81
After EM 24,667 18,005 723 709 126 0.92 42 2.29 0.437 0.017 0.25 1.33 2.20 6.55
Mean Before EM 79,013 77,696 760 677 54 8.51 403 3.78 1.140 0.075 0.65 8.30 5.27 17.47
After EM 22,093 22,374 1020 902 128 8.99 419 3.89 0.488 0.038 0.39 9.98 4.89 15.34
Mean difference after and before EM  − 72.04%  − 71.20% 34.25% 33.33% 137.04% 5.67% 3.88% 2.84%  − 57.19%  − 49.4%  − 40.58% 20.29%  − 7.11%  − 12.23%
Mann Whitney U Test U-value 1227 1113 1375 1321.5 1212 787 870 1039.5 1897.5 1764 1356.5 537.5 961.5 755.5
z-score  − 4.19585  − 4.65108  − 3.59558  − 3.81111  − 4.25225  − 2.8597  − 1.65712 0.07906 3.96203 3.81245 0.65932  − 4.3344  − 0.9678  − 2.42999
p  < 0.00001  < 0.00001 0.00032 0.00014  < 0.00001 0.00424 0.09692 0.93624 0.00008 0.00014 0.50926  < 0.00001 0.33204 0.0151

Designations in the table: italics — values statistically significant for p ≤ 0.05