Larson 2013.
Methods | CBA study | |
Participants | Index: 237 HIV+ tea pluckers with a CD4 count < 350 who began ART between 2004 and 2007 Control: Pool of workers from the 13,178 general work force population (Kenya) |
|
Interventions | Intervention: Pharmacological, ART Control: Healthy, untreated general work force |
|
Outcomes | Employment:
|
|
Notes | HIV | |
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
14. Blinding (Subjects) | Low risk | Participants were unaware of intervention. |
15. Blinding (outcome assessors) | Low risk | Not reported. Objective outcomes that should have been unaffected by blinding. |
16. Retrospective unplanned subgroup analysis | Unclear risk | Retrospective study, data dredging not clear. |
17. Follow‐up | Low risk | Follow‐ups conducted for both index and reference at 6‐month intervals beginning 24 months pre‐ART until 24 months post‐ART. |
18. Statistical tests | Low risk | Mean difference (95% confidence interval) |
19. Compliance | Unclear risk | Compliance to ART was not monitored or insured. ART adherence is required for survival, therefore compliance is highly likely. |
20. Outcome measures | Low risk | All predetermined outcome measures were analyzed and reported. |
21. Selection Bias (population) | Low risk | Study used all HIV+ persons who visited the tea plantation hospitals and healthcare clinics. All participants were employees of two tea plantations in the Kericho District of Kenya. However, it is important to note that some participants in the reference group were likely HIV+ but were undiagnosed or had not declared their HIV status as positive. This could have impacted the results. |
22. Selection bias (time) | Low risk | All participants were monitored between 2006‐2009. |
23. Randomization | High risk | No randomization for index group. Index group was matched with four references who were randomized into subestate groups. |
24. Allocation concealment | Unclear risk | Retrospective, non‐randomized study. Did not report the use of adequate sequence generation or allocation concealment techniques. |
25. Adjustment for confounding | High risk | Adjustment for gender outcome differences. Age differences not addressed. SES differences not addressed. Disease severity not addressed. Migration differences not addressed. |
26. Incomplete outcome data | High risk | 6% attrition in index group addressed. No attrition data reported for controls. Data for workers in the general work force was incomplete due to a change in the management system resulting in the reassigning of employment identification numbers. |
Baseline comparability | High risk | No baseline demographics were reported for the reference group. The index group mean age for women was 39.4 (27.4‐53) and for men was 39.5 (24.9‐54.4). The average years of experience for women was 8.2 (1‐24) years and for men was 7.7 (0.5‐23) years. Median baseline CD4 counts for women were 178 (91‐243) and for men were 153.3 (85‐215). |