Skip to main content
. 2023 Nov 21;25(1):e14208. doi: 10.1002/acm2.14208

TABLE 1.

Quantitative analysis table for phantom cases.

Phantom Energy (MeV) σ/D¯ (%)

Pγ(1%/1mm) (%)

Pγ(2%/2mm) (%) TARCHER (s) TTOPAS (s)
Water EM 100 0.49 99.7 100 0.82 1998
200 0.54 99.8 100 1.73 6442
Water 100 0.54 98.7 99.9 1.49 2333
200 0.77 99.5 100 3.59 6822
Water 0T 150 0.63 99.4 99.9 2.42 5462
0.5T 150 0.64 99.4 100 2.79 5451
1T 150 0.65 99.2 99.9 2.74 5443
1.5T 150 0.64 99.1 100 2.73 5485
2T 150 0.64 98.9 100 2.74 5430
Bone 100 0.55 96.5 99.2 1.33 1974
200 0.74 98.8 99.7 3.18 5399
Tissue 100 0.54 99.4 100 1.51 2984
200 0.75 99.0 99.9 3.65 7526
Inhomogeneous 200 0.84 99.6 100 4.54 9163