Skip to main content
. 2024 Jan 19;19(1):e0295811. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0295811

Table 4. Average percentage difference between the aquaponics and hydroponic control treatments for every macronutrient (NO3-N, NH4-N, K, P, Ca, Mg, and S) added in the form of inorganic fertiliser.

Percentage difference * FM BSF
Nitrate–NO3-N - 29.21 - 25.85
Ammonia–NH4-N - 49.33 - 48.05
Potassium–K - 8.40 - 10.67
Phosphorus—P - 2.55 - 0.17
Calcium—Ca - 53.30 - 53.75
Magnesium—Mg - 50.62 - 52.58
Sulphur—S - 93.66 - 91.77
Total inorganic fertiliser - 31.73 - 31.68

FM: fish meal-based diet waste water. BSF: Black Soldier Fly meal-based diet waste water.

* a(IFn,j)—mean(IFn,control)) / mean(IFn,control)) * 100; where Dif_IFn is the percentage difference of the amount of inorganic fertiliser for the specific macronutrient n, IFn,j is the amount (g) of the inorganic fertiliser for the specific macronutrient n in the j treatment, and IFn,control is the amount (g) of the inorganic fertiliser for the specific macronutrient n in the control HP treatment.