Table 1.
Authors | Study design | States | Sample characteristics | Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|
Boggs et al. (2005) (27) | Longitudinal Study (Collaborative Longitudinal Personality Disorders Study) |
United States |
N = 668 individuals ♀ 64% ♂ 36% |
BPD criteria, except for impulsivity, tended to underestimate the level of global functioning in ♀ as compared to ♂ |
Henry and Cohen (1983) (14) | Cross sectional | United States |
N = 277 undergraduate and graduate students ♀ 197 ♂ 80 |
Healthy ♂ > healthy ♀ (BPD characteristics) |
Hoertel et al. (2014) (45) | Epidemiologic survey Second wave of the National Epidemiologic Survey on Alcohol and Related Conditions (NESARC) |
United States |
N = 34.653 subjects ♀ 19,984 ♂ 14,497 |
♀ < ♂ impulsivity at lower degree of borderline personality disorder severity ♀ > ♂affective instability, self-mutilating behavios/suicidality and chronic feelings of emptiness. |
Jane et al. (2007) (38) | Cross sectional study | United States |
N = 599 subjects ♀ 284 ♂ 315 |
None of the BPD criteria demonstrated gender bias |
Martin et al. (2023) (46) | Cross sectional study | France |
N = 22,060 undergraduate students (females) ♀ 64.9% ♂ 35.1% |
♀ > ♂ self-harm/suicidality, affective lability, abandonment ♀ < ♂ impulsivity, and anger |
Morey and Ochoa (1989) (41) | Cross sectional study | United States |
N = 291 patients N = 101 psychiatrists +190 psychologists |
BPD ♀ were more likely to be misdiagnosed with BPD when both the physician and the patient were females |
Morey et al. (2002) (42) | Cross sectional study | United States | N = 101 male and female college students | No gender differences in the self-ratings of BPD criteria and the criteria were retained equally problematic for each gender |
Sharp et al. (2014) (43) | Cross sectional study | United States |
N = 747 psychiatric inpatient ♀ 371 ♂ 376 |
♂ > ♀ uncontrolled anger and impulsivity criteria |
BPD, borderline personality disorder; ♂, men; ♀, women.