Skip to main content
. 2023 Dec 19;13(1):101019. doi: 10.1016/j.imr.2023.101019

Table 4.

Evaluation measures in disease pathological syndrome identification.

Model Evaluation Measures Excess Cold syndrome Excess Heat syndrome Deficiency Cold syndrome Deficiency Heat syndrome Qi Deficiency syndrome Blood Deficiency syndrome Qi Stagnation syndrome Blood Stasis syndrome Phlegm Fluid Retention syndrome Critical syndrome
BERT Precision 0.8542 0.8402 0.8566 0.8933 0.8870 0.9029 0.8347 0.8562 0.8781 0.8576
Recall 0.9108 0.9282 0.9102 0.9257 0.9138 0.9164 0.8843 0.8863 0.9283 0.9256
F1 0.8816 0.8820 0.8826 0.9092 0.9002 0.9095 0.8588 0.8709 0.9025 0.8903
TEXTCNN Precision 0.8724 0.8584 0.8446 0.8310 0.8014 0.8036 0.7915 0.8746 0.8626 0.8207
Recall 0.7963 0.8735 0.8126 0.8323 0.8782 0.8088 0.8280 0.8243 0.8746 0.7838
F1 0.8326 0.8658 0.8283 0.8316 0.8381 0.8062 0.8093 0.8487 0.8685 0.8018
LSTM RNN Precision 0.8386 0.8681 0.8022 0.8401 0.7996 0.8199 0.8837 0.8621 0.8217 0.8163
Recall 0.8086 0.8677 0.8132 0.8699 0.8459 0.7890 0.7895 0.8839 0.8398 0.8848
F1 0.8233 0.8679 0.8076 0.8547 0.8221 0.8042 0.8339 0.8729 0.8306 0.8491
LSTM ATTENTION Precision 0.8945 0.8537 0.8865 0.8595 0.8720 0.8470 0.8181 0.8881 0.8047 0.8268
Recall 0.8445 0.8700 0.8901 0.8012 0.8406 0.8356 0.8296 0.8311 0.8796 0.8885
F1 0.8688 0.8618 0.8883 0.8293 0.8560 0.8413 0.8238 0.8586 0.8405 0.8565
TCM-BERT-CNN Precision 0.9486 0.9173 0.9513 0.9212 0.9329 0.9097 0.9416 0.9312 0.8840 0.9402
Recall 0.9594 0.8735 0.8978 0.8874 0.9266 0.9062 0.9336 0.9028 0.9355 0.9008
F1 0.9540 0.8949 0.9238 0.9039 0.9297 0.9079 0.9376 0.9168 0.9090 0.9201