TABLE 1.
Study | Study design | Study population | Total TMA incidence | Systemic TMA incidence | Renal-limited TMA incidence | Study follow-up time (month) | C4d+ | C4d− | Tacrolimus base regimen | Cyclosporine base regimen | Acute antibody-mediated rejection | Acute cell-mediated rejection | ABO incompatible |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Baid, 1999 [33] | Single-arm | KAR | 3.2% (12/379) | 3.2% (12/379) | 84 | ||||||||
Braet, 2016 [34] | Single-arm | KAR | 2.20% | N/A | 428 | ||||||||
Caires, 2012 [35] | Single-arm | KAR | 1.1% (17/1,549) | 1.1% (17/1,549) | 132 | ||||||||
Dessaix, 2019 [36] | Single-arm | KAB | 4.80% | 6.6 | |||||||||
Doradla, 2020 [37] | Single-arm | KAR | 0.85% (17/2,000) | 0.2% (4/2,000) | 0.65% (13/2,000) | ||||||||
Fortin, 2004 [38] | Cohort | KAR | 3.53% (13/368) | 3.53% (13/368) | 1.29% (3/233) | 3.70% (2/54) | |||||||
Franco, 2003 [39] | Single-arm | KAR | 0.26% (10/3,862) | 0.26% (10/3,862) | 24 | ||||||||
Futamura, 2020 [40] | Single-arm | KAR | 5.16% (69/1,336) | 211 | |||||||||
Gumber, 2014 [41] | Single-arm | KAR | 2.89% (34/1,175) | 72 | |||||||||
Kocak, 2015 [42] | Single-arm | KAR | 2.72% (13/477) | 2.72% (13/477) | 36 | 2.72% (13/477) | |||||||
Langer, 2001 [43] | Single-arm | KAR | 1.5% (10/672) | 1.5% (10/672) | 212 | 1.5% (10/672) | |||||||
Nava, 2014 [44] | Cohort | KAR | 7.3% (36/496) | 180 | N/A | ||||||||
Oyen, 2006 [45] | Single-arm | KAR | 0.82% (7/850) | 48 | 0.82% (7/850) | ||||||||
Ozedemir, 2018 [46] | Single-arm | KAR | 33.33% (30/90) | 17.6% (9/51) | |||||||||
Reynolds, 2003 [3] | Cohort | KAR | 4.9/1,000 PY | ||||||||||
Santos, 2003 [47] | Single-arm | KAR | 5% (6/115) | 5% (6/115) | |||||||||
Satoskar, 2010 [16] | Single-arm | KAB | 13.6% (33/243) | 23.6% (6/715) | |||||||||
Schwimmer, 2003 [4] | Single-arm | KAR | 3% (21/742) | 1.07% (8/742) | 1.75% (13/742) | 52% (11/21) | 48% (10/21) | ||||||
Tasaki, 2019 [17] | Cohort | KAR | 7.5% (15/201) | 7.5% (15/201) | 214 | 17.2% (15/87) | |||||||
Zarifian, 1999 [48] | Single-arm | KAR | 13.8% (26/188) | 1.06% (2/188) | 12.7% (24/188) |
KAR, kidney allograft recipients; KAB, kidney allograft biopsies; PY, person-years; TMA, thrombotic microangiopathy.