Table 6.
Trial | Sample Size | Inclusion Criteria | RT Technique | Fractionation | Outcomes | Median Follow-Up | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
SOCCAR [98] | 130 | Stage III | 3D/IMRT 4D CT allowed |
55Gy/20 fx Concurrent vs. sequential chemo |
TRTM | 2.93 years | TRTM 2.9% (CI 0.36–10.2%) concurrent vs. 1.7% (CI 0.043–9.1%) sequential; RR 1.25 (CI 0.55, 2.84) |
CHISEL [93] | 101 | Stage I/II, inoperable or refusing surgery | 3D | SBRT 54 Gy/3 fx 48 Gy/4 fx 66 Gy/33 fx, or 50 Gy/20 fx |
Time to local treatment failure | 2.1 years | Local progression: 14% SABR vs. 31% standard radiotherapy; SABR had improved FFF (HR 0.32, p = 0.0077) |
RTOG 0915 [105,106] | 94 | Stage I/II peripheral inoperable | IMRT 4D CT allowed |
34 Gy/1 fraction 48 Gy/4 fx |
Rate of grade 3 or higher | 4 years | Toxicity rates (Grade 3+): 34 Gy (Arm 1): 2.6% 48 Gy (Arm 2): 11.1% Primary tumor failure: 34 Gy: 10.6% (CI: 3.3–23.1%) vs. 48 Gy: 6.8% (CI: 1.7–16.9%) OS: 34 Gy: 29.6% (CI: 16.2–44.4%) vs. 48 Gy: 41.1% (CI: 26.6–55.1%) |
Legend: TRTM: treatment-related mortality; FFF: freedom from failure.