Carlisle, 1972 [1] |
Sodium metasilicate |
Control |
1 ppm |
X |
- |
Chicks |
1 day |
Reduced growth rate, shorter leg bones with smaller circumferences and thinner cortices in control, control tibias and femurs fracture more easily |
Supplemented |
100 ppm |
Carlisle 1976 [6] |
Sodium metasilicate |
Control |
<3 ppm |
0 mg |
- |
Chicks |
1 day |
Better growth, higher hexosamine content and percent in articular cartilage, greater silicon content in comb, less water content in tibia and femur with supplementation, no difference in percent ash |
Supplemented |
100 ppm |
Carlisle, 1980a [4] |
Sodium metasilicate |
Control |
1 ppm |
X |
- |
Chicks |
1 day |
Greater percentage and total amount of hexosamine and greater percentage of collagen in tibias from supplemented vs control, Si-deficient tibias had lesions and changes in epiphyseal cartilage especially in proliferative zone |
Supplemented |
250 ppm |
Carlisle, 1980b [3] |
Sodium metasilicate |
Control |
1 ppm |
X |
- |
Chicks |
1 day |
Si-deficient skulls had less trabeculae and calcification, reduced collagen content |
Supplemented |
250 ppm |
Carlisle, 1981 [37] |
Sodium metasilicate |
Control |
1 ppm |
X |
- |
Chicks |
1 day |
Skull abnormalities in Si-deficient chicks from less collagen concentration in bones |
Supplemented |
250 ppm |
Merkley and Miller, 1983 [38] |
Sodium metasilicate |
Control |
- |
X |
- |
Chicks |
1 day |
Humeri strength decreased during immobilization in control but remained similar to unrestricted humeri strength with metasilicate |
Sodium metasilicate |
74 ppm |
Watkins, Vagnoni, and Southern, 1989 [39] |
Sodium zeolite A |
0% |
- |
0 mg |
- |
Chicks |
4 days |
SZA with excess Ca decreased weight gain and tibia ash |
0.75% |
90.3 mg |
Elliot and Edwards, 1991 [40] |
Sodium metasilicate |
Basal 1
|
0.01 mg |
0 mg |
0.02 |
Chicks |
1 day |
High silicon inclusion reduced feed efficiency, no difference in tibial ash |
25 1
|
0.20 mg |
0.66 |
50 1
|
0.46 mg |
1.53 |
150 1
|
1.44 mg |
4.78 |
250 1
|
2.72 mg |
7.62 |
Watkins and Southern, 1992 [41] |
Sodium zeolite A |
0% SZA |
- |
X |
- |
Chicks |
4 days |
Plasma Ca or alkaline phosphatase unaffected by SZA, reduction in plasma P but increase in tibia Mn, Zn, Cu, and Al with SZA |
0.75% SZA |
Scheidler, 1993 [42] |
Aluminosilicates |
Control |
- |
X |
- |
Chicks |
1 day |
Novasil increased bone ash, Ethacal decreased bone ash, supplementation decreased serum Cl |
Ethacal |
163 mg |
279 |
Novasil |
288 mg |
506 |
Perlite |
357 mg |
543 |
Zeobrite |
333 mg |
514 |
Kayongo-Male and Julson, 2008 [26] |
Tetraethyl-orthosilicate |
Groups based on supplemented Si levels |
|
0 ppm |
- |
Turkeys |
1 day |
Moment of inertia and plasma calcium lower with high supplementation, no differences in other physical or mechanical properties |
135 ppm |
270 ppm |
540 ppm |
Sgavioli et al., 2016 [30] |
Not given |
0 mg Supplement |
- |
X |
- |
Chicks |
1 day |
Si supplementation had no effect on bone density or breaking strength, bone ash, phosphorus, zinc, and manganese increased without increasing bone calcium |
0.5 mg Supplement |
244 mg |
150 |
1.0 mg Supplement |
488 mg |
300 |
1.5 mg Supplement |
740 mg |
450 |
Scholey et al., 2018 [32] |
Monomeric silicic acid |
Control 1
|
55.8 mg |
X |
114 |
Chicks |
1 day |
Improved tibia breaking strength and tibial Si at 1000 mg/L supplementation, foot and tibia ash increased in the 500 mg/L, no other significant differences in bone measures |
200 mg/L |
16.2 mg |
138 |
500 mg/L |
39.5 mg |
166 |
1000 mg/L 1
|
79.5 mg |
280 |
Pritchard et al., 2020 [43] |
Orthosilicic acid |
Control |
2.9 mg |
X |
4.1 |
Chicks |
1 day |
Supplementation reduced serum boron and increased serum calcium; bone density, morphology, and strength measures were similar among groups |
Normal |
133 mg |
147 |
High |
804 mg |
863 |