Table 2.
Study environmentb | Design characteristics of field intervention | Outcome measures presented for rodents, Ix. scapularis and humans | |||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Rodents | Questing ticks | Humans | |||||||||||||
Bait box | Treatment | Controlc | Bait box placement on treated residential properties | Rebaiting of deployed boxes | Treatment years | Pretreatment data for outcome measures | Abundance | Bait box useg | Tick infestation | Pathogen infectionh | Abundance | Pathogen infectionh | Tick encounters | Tick-borne diseaseh | Reference |
Prototype | RP (n = 154) | W (n = 5) | Boxes spaced 10 m apart in row along ecotone of maintained landscaping (mostly lawn) with woods, brush or stone walls; extra boxes placed near wood-piles and outbuildings. | Yes | 1999–2001d | Yese | Yesf | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | No | Dolan et al. (2004) |
Maxforce TMS | RP (n = 4) | RP (n = 3); W (n = 1) | Boxes spaced 25 m apart in rows (i) along lawn ecotone with woods and (ii) 10 m into wooded habitat | Yes | 2008–2009 | Yese | No | Yes | Yes | N/Ai | Yes | n/a i | No | No | Dolan et al. (2017) |
SELECT TCSa | RP (n = 12) | W (n = 1) | Boxes spaced 10 m apart in rows located (i) 3 m into woods from ecotone with lawn and (ii) 13 m into wooded habitat (as needed depending on extent of wooded habitat on the property) | No | 2012–2013 | Yese | Yesf | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | No | No | No | Schulze et al. (2017) |
SELECT TCSa | RP (n = 6) | W (n = 1) | Boxes spaced 20 m apart in rows located (i) 10 m into woods from ecotone with lawn and (ii) 30 m into wooded habitat (as needed depending on extent of wooded habitat on the property) | No | 2014–2015 | Yese | Yesf | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | No | No | No | Jordan and Schulze (2019) |
SELECT TCSa | RP (n = 269) | RP (n = 269) | Boxes spaced 10 m apart in row located 3 m into woods or brush from ecotone with lawn, with additional boxes placed along unsealed rock piles and wood piles located at or near the wooded edge | No | 2012–2014; or 2013–2015 | Yese | No | No | No | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Hinckley et al. (2021) |
SELECT TCSa | RP (n~220 RPs in six neighborhood clusters) | RP (n~220 RPs in six neighborhood clusters) | Boxes placed ≥10 m apart in all habitat types sampled for ticks; deployed in protected locations (e.g., along building foundations and under vegetation) | No | 2017–2020 | No | No | No | Yes | Noj | Yes | Noj | Yes | Yes | Keesing et al. (2022) |
SELECT TCS product label recommendation language for box deployment: “Boxes are placed a minimum of 10 m (30 feet) apart near the edge of maintained landscaping and woodlots and/or brush. For woodlots that extend farther than 40 feet an additional row of units should be considered for maximum control. The second row should be placed 30–40 feet from the first set of boxes.”.
RP, residential properties; W, woodland sites.
Control areas without bait boxes (Dolan et al., 2004, 2017; Schulze et al., 2017; Jordan and Schulze, 2019) or with placebo bait boxes lacking fipronil (Hinckley et al., 2021; Keesing et al., 2022).
A single treatment year for the majority of properties (n = 110), with smaller numbers treated over 2 years (n = 31) or three years (n = 13).
Including collection of questing nymphs in the year the treatment started as nymphs of that cohort (resulting from larvae fed on hosts in the summer of the previous year) were not considered to be impacted by the treatment in the first year.
Based on data presented for both number of rodents captured and number of trap days/nights.
Based on removal of bait from the boxes.
Pathogens and diseases associated with Ix. scapularis, including Borrelia burgdorferi sensu lato (Lyme disease), Anaplasma phagocytophilum (anaplasmosis), and Babesia microti (babesiosis).
Not applicable; only measures related to tick infestation of rodents or abundance of questing ticks is considered here as the intervention also included antibiotic treatment of the rodents which would impact pathogen infection in both rodents and questing ticks.
Data were collected but not included in this publication.