Table 2. Characteristics of included peer reviewed studies.
Authors and year | Jurisdiction | Population | Amount of advance notice given to workers prior to work start time | Sleep and/or fatigue measures | Sleep and/or fatigue outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Harknett, Schneider, and Wolfe (2020) | United States | Workers employed by large retail and food service firms | “How far in advance do you usually know what days
and hours you will need to work at [EMPLOYER NAME]?” Responses categorised as “less than 1 wk,” “1–2 wk,” “2–3 wk,” “3–4 wk,” and “4 or more wk” |
Four self-report questions. “During the past month, how would you rate your sleep quality overall?” (1=poor, 4=very good) “During the past month, how often did you have difficulty falling asleep?” (1=never, 2=1–2 times per month, 3=weekly, 4=multiple times per week, 5=every day) “During the past month, how often did you wake up repeatedly during sleep?” (1=never, 5=every day) “During the past month, how often did you wake up feeling exhausted/ fatigued?” (1=never, 5=every day) |
Significantly better sleep quality with increased
advance notice (p>0.05): • <1 wk notice: ref • 0.07 point increase in sleep quality with 1–2 wk notice • 0.07 point increase in sleep quality with 1–2 wk notice • 0.10 point increase in sleep quality with 2–3 wk notice • 0.14 point increase in sleep quality with 3–4 wk notice • 0.14 point increase in sleep quality with 4+ wk notice Significantly less difficulty falling asleep with increased advance notice (p>0.05): • <1 wk notice: ref • 0.10 point decrease in difficulty falling asleep with 1–2 wk notice • 0.12 point decrease in difficulty falling asleep with 2–3 wk notice • 0.16 point decrease in difficulty falling asleep with 3–4 wk notice • 0.17 point decrease in difficulty falling asleep with 4+ wk notice Significantly less sleep disturbance with increased advance notice (p>0.05): • <1 wk notice: ref • 0.09 point decrease in sleep disturbance with 1–2 wk notice • 0.09 point decrease in sleep disturbance with 2–3 wk notice • 0.14 point decrease in sleep disturbance with 3–4 wk notice • 0.17 point decrease in sleep disturbance with 4+ wk notice Significantly less waking up feeling fatigued with increased advance notice (p>0.05): • <1 wk notice: ref • 0.08 point decrease fatigue with 1–2 wk notice • 0.14 point decrease in fatigue with 2–3 wk notice • 0.18 point decrease in fatigue with 3–4 wk notice • 0.17 point decrease in fatigue with 4+ wk notice |
Harknett, Schneider, and Irwin (2021) | United States |
Seattle treatment group:
Individuals who reported working in Seattle and whose employers were of the size and type that would be covered by the Secure Scheduling ordinance. Comparison group: Workers employed by the exact same set of companies covered by the Seattle law but employed in other large US cities |
Seattle treatment group: >2 wk advance notice
Comparison group: <2 wk advance notice |
Percentage of respondents who reported ‘good’ or ‘very good’ sleep quality. | 11% increase in ‘good’ or ‘very good’ sleep quality
for Seattle treatment group when the Secure Scheduling ordinance was introduced.
No increase in sleep quality for comparison group. |
Schneider and Harknett (2019) | United States | Retail and food service workers employed at 80 large companies. | Amount of advance notice given of schedule: · 0–2 d · 3–6 d · 1–2 wk · 2 wk or more |
Sleep quality rated as very good, good, fair, or poor used to create a dichotomous variable (very good and good versus fair and poor). | Significantly poorer sleep when 0–2 or 3–6 d’ notice
given, as compared with 2 wk or more (ref). · 0.35 point decrease in sleep quality with 0–2 d’ notice* · 0.27 point decrease in sleep quality with 3–6 d’ notice* · 0.9 point decrease in sleep quality with 1–2 wk’ notice · More than 2 wk’ notice: ref |