Skip to main content
. 2013 Dec 1;131(6):411–421. doi: 10.1590/1516-3180.2013.1316667

Table 2. Characteristics of the randomized controlled trials that compared the kinds of anesthesia for orthopedic surgery and their contribution to the meta-analysis.

Study (year) Anesthesia n Surgery Outcomes studied Remark
Berggren et al.15 GA 29 Femoral neck fracture surgery Stroke, cognitive dysfunction, pneumonia Only fully lucid patients were included in the study
EA 28
Bigler et al.16 GA 20 Hip surgery Mortality, cognitive dysfunction Patients with severe dementia, cancer and psychiatric or disseminated neurological disease were not studied
SA 20
Casati et al.18 GA 15 Hemiarthroplasty of the hip Length of hospitalization, cognitive dysfunction One woman in each group
USA 15
Davis et al.22 GA 68 Emergency hip surgery Mortality, stroke, myocardial infarction General anesthetic technique may not have been the same for all patients
SP 64
Davis et al.23 GA 279 Hip fracture surgery Mortality, length of hospitalization Multicenter study; the length of follow-up was not the same for all patients
SA 259
Eroglu et al.25 GA 20 Total hip replacement Blood transfusion requirements Hypotensive anesthesia was used in both groups
EA 20
Hole et al.27 GA 31 Total hip arthroplasty Mortality, myocardial infarction, degree of satisfaction Only changes in mental status were analyzed, such as amnesia regarding personal data and disorientation relating to time, place and situation
EA 29
Jones et al.29 GA 72 Elective hip or knee replacement Mortality, cognitive dysfunction Patients over the age of 60 years
SA 74
Juelsgaard et al.30 GA SA 14 15 Hip fracture surgery Mortality, myocardial infarction, length of hospitalization The authors quote: "Patients with known coronary artery disease scheduled for osteosynthesis of a femoral neck fracture were included in the study". The exclusion criteria were: uncooperative patients, recent myocardial infarction, unstable angina pectoris, significant aortic stenosis and other established contraindications for spinal anesthesia
McKenzie et al.34 GA 51 Femoral neck fracture surgery Mortality, myocardial infarction Patients over the age of 65 years
SA 49
McLaren et al. 35 GA 29 Femoral neck fracture surgery Mortality More patients in the spinal anesthesia group had respiratory problems
SA 26
Nielson et al. 37 GA 39 Elective knee arthroplasty Cognitive dysfunction Patients between 60 and 86 years of age
SA 25
Racle et al. 38 GA 35 Hip surgery Mortality, myocardial infarction, stroke, cognitive dysfunction The patients were women
SA 35
Riis et al. 39 GA 10 Total hip replacement arthroplasty Cognitive dysfunction The authors reported data from a third group with GA and EA combined
EA 10
Valentin et al.41 GA Hip fracture surgery Mortality Premedication was not given to high-risk patients; there were more high-risk patients in the spinal anesthesia group
SA
White et al.42 GA 20 Femoral neck fracture surgery Mortality, cognitive dysfunction, pneumonia Patients in the spinal anesthesia group received general anesthetic drugs reported as "light anesthesia"
SA 19
Williams-Russo et al.44 GA 134 Total knee replacement Mortality, length of hospitalization, cognitive dysfunction The authors developed their own questionnaire to evaluate cognitive dysfunction
EA 128