Table 3.
Intervention description.
Author | Name | Rationale | Materials | Procedures | Who provided | How | Where | When and how much | Tailoring | Modifications | Fidelity- planned | Fidelity - delivered |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Hartvigsen, Lauritzen [47] | Intervention group | Bobath principle: reduce load on the body by maximising patient participation, reducing friction and maintaining natural body positions | Low-tech equipment | Practical training on lifting techniques and body mechanics according to the Bobath principle. | Train the trainer model. Nurse or nurse aid instructor trained by a physiotherapist skilled in body mechanics and lifting techniques | Face- to-face, group | NR | 1 × 1hr per week session for 2 yrs +4 × 2hr psychology sessions |
Encouraged to provide feedback on transfers during sessions. | NR | NR | NR |
Svensson, Stroyer [39] | LBP Prevention program | Improve fitness to cope with sudden spinal loading, improve transfer techniques to reduce spinal loading, improve psychological coping strategies to LBP | Low-tech equipment | Physical training: unexpected trunk loading and balance. Patient transfers: theoretical education and practical exercises. Stress management: theoretical exercises and group discussions to increase coping capacity |
School teaching teams | Face- to-face, group | NR | Physical training (48 × 1 hr). Patient transfer technique education (20 h) and Stress management (22 h). | NR | NR | All students in intervention group | NR |
Svensson, Marott [40] | LBP Prevention program | Improve fitness to cope with sudden spinal loading, improve transfer techniques to reduce spinal loading, improve psychological coping strategies to LBP | Low-tech equipment | Physical training: unexpected trunk loading and balance. Patient transfers: theoretical education and practical exercises. Stress management: theoretical exercises and group discussions to increase coping capacity |
School teaching teams | Face- to-face, group | NR | Physical training (48 × 1 hr). Patient transfer technique education (20 h) and Stress management (22 h). | NR | NR | All participants in intervention group | NR |
Black, Metcalfe [46] | Transfer, Lifting and Repositioning (TLR) Program | To prevent patient handling-related musculoskeletal injuries | A course booklet and training materials, low- and high-tech equipment | Education on anatomy, injuries, body mechanics, personal health, lifting and patient handling procedures, standardized patient handling needs assessment, and patient handling algorithms. Practical patient handling skill component | NR | Face- to-face, group | NR | Initial 1 × 8hr session + on-ward coaching + 1 h/year follow-up | NR | NR | Mandatory for all direct care working | NR |
Lim, Black [48] | Transfer, Lifting and Repositioning (TLR) Program | To prevent patient handling-related musculoskeletal injuries | A course booklet and training materials. low- and high-tech equipment | Education on anatomy, injuries, body mechanics, personal health, lifting and patient handling procedures, standardized patient handling needs assessment, and patient handling algorithms. Practical patient handling skill component | NR | Face- to-face, group | NR | Initial 1 × 8hr session + on-ward coaching + 1 h/year follow-up | NR | NR | Mandatory for all direct care working | NR |
Jaromi, Kukla [44] | Spine care for nurses | Increase knowledge of spinal biomechanics and patient handling techniques and strengthen muscles in order to avert microtrauma | Written materials detailing exercise program and patient handling skills, equipment use not reported | Theoretical sessions to educate on the spinal anatomy, biomechanics, injury prevention and lifting techniques. Practical sessions to practise spinal strengthening exercises and patient transfers according to the Dotte and Bobath methods | NR | Face- to-face, group | NR | 2 × 60min sessions per week for 12 weeks | NR | NR | All participants in intervention group | NR |
Jensen, Gonge [45] | Transfer Technique Intervention | Education based on Stockholm training concept to reduce biomechanical load on the back, minimise asymmetric posture and avoid sudden loads | Low- and high-tech equipment | Practical classroom education with 30 transfer situations taught, followed by implementation period of on-site training | Classroom sessions: project supervisors trained in Stockholm training concept. On-site group participants with additional 30hrs training | Face-to-face, group | On-site training in usual work setting | 2 × 4hrs classroom education, 2–6 months of on-site training | On-site training adapted to individual work situations | NR | All staff | NR |
Shojaei, Tavafian [42] | Educational Program | Education based on social cognitive theory increase likelihood of healthy behaviours of safe patient handling | Equipment use not reported | Education on self-efficacy, self-regulation, highlighting outcome expectation and emotional coping related to safe postures while moving patients. Education methods included, skills training, negotiation, role-playing, goal setting and self-assessment. | Health education specialist | Face- to-face, group | NR | 4 × 2hr sessions | Individualised goal setting and addressing of barriers to safe handling | NR | All participants | NR |
Warming, Wiese [41] | Transfer Training | Train the trainer model used to adapt knowledge from an expert to their local setting. Transfer techniques taught based on gravity, friction and lever arm principles | Low-tech equipment | Trainers trained colleagues on the ward. No further information about specific activities | Nurses with 4 days of training | Face-to-face | Hospital | Trainer available on ward for 2 × 6week blocks to train staff. No indication of dose per participant | Training individualised to wards and on the job situations | NR | All ward nurses | No. who complete training reported |
Transfer Training + Physical Training | As per TT with addition of physical training to increase physical capacity | Low-tech equipment, gym equipment and heart rate monitor watch | As per Transfer Training with addition of circuit training for aerobic fitness of 5 × 6mins, Strength of 4 × 5mins, 5min cool-down | NR | face- to-face, group | Hospital | Physical training: 2 × 1 h/week for 8 weeks | Programs individualised to work at 70–90 % of VO2 max | NR | All participants in the TT + PT group | No. who complete part of intervention reported (Physical Training reported, not Transfer Training) |
Abbreviations: NR – not reported, LBP – lower back pain, VO2 max – maximum volume of oxygen consumption.
Equipment category descriptions: 1. Use of equipment not reported 2. Use of low-tech aids such as slide sheets and slings 3. Use of high-tech equipment such as hoists and lifting machines.