Skip to main content
. 2013 Oct 1;131(5):338–350. doi: 10.1590/1516-3180.2013.1315519

Table 2. Evaluation of methodological quality using Bogardus method.

Study 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Aydemir et al.21 no yes yes yes yes no yes
Härtel et al.9 no yes yes yes yes no yes
Abu-Maziad et al.22 no yes yes yes yes no no
Auriti et al.23 no yes yes yes yes no yes
Koroglu et al.24 no yes yes yes yes no yes
Spiegler et al.25 no yes yes yes yes no yes
Abdel-Hady et al.26 no yes yes yes yes no yes
Bertalan et al.27 no yes yes yes yes no no
Reiman et al.28 no yes yes yes yes no yes
Dzwonek et al.29 no yes yes yes yes no yes
van Der Zwet et al.30 no yes yes no no no yes
Schueller et al.31 no yes yes yes no yes yes
Derzbach et al.32 no yes yes yes yes no no
Härtel et al.33 no yes yes yes yes no yes
Baier et al.34 no yes yes yes yes yes yes
Göpel et al.35 no yes yes yes yes no yes
John Baier et al.36 no yes yes yes yes no no
Hedberg et al.37 no yes yes yes yes no no
Ahrens et al.38 no yes yes yes yes no yes
Bessler et al.39 no yes yes yes yes no yes
Harding et al.40 yes yes yes yes yes yes yes
Treszl et al.41 no yes yes yes yes no yes

1 = reproducibility; 2 = definition of cases; 3 = adequacy of cases; 4 = definition of control; 5 = adequacy of control; 6 = objectivity; 7 = quantification of results.