Skip to main content
. 2023 Dec 5;7(1):e267. doi: 10.1017/cts.2023.688

Table 2.

Types of sensitivity analyses described and their advantages and disadvantages

Type of sensitivity analysis Disadvantages Advantages Example
Semiparametric
  • Requires arbitrary models for unmeasured variables.

  • Requires positing plausible values for the unintelligible coefficients of the above model.

  • Mathematical convenience.

  • Franks et al. [26] – antihypertensives and diastolic blood pressure.

Nonparametric
  • Typically, none, although some methods such as instances of the E-value might use implausible assumptions [31].

  • Requires positing plausible values for intelligible scientific quantities (e.g., spontaneous probability of Chagas seroreversion).

  • Nifurtimox on Chagas disease, discussed in this manuscript.

Negative controls
  • Does not conclusively guarantee that associations are causal.

  • Requires positing an outcome with a null treatment effect, which is often feasible.

  • Dickerman et al. [44] – COVID vaccines

Identification bounds
  • Bounds are often too wide to be informative.

  • Operates with few or no assumptions.

  • Bhattacharya et al. [38] – right heart catheterization and 30-day mortality