Table 1.
Cohort Studies | |||
---|---|---|---|
Prospective | Retrospective | Case-Control Studies | |
Study Group | Exposed persons | Exposed persons | Persons with the disease (cases): |
Comparison Group | Nonexposed persons | Nonexposed persons | Persons without disease (controls): |
Outcome Measurements | Incidence in the exposed And incidence in the nonexposed |
Incidence in the exposed And incidence in the nonexposed |
Proportion of cases exposed And proportion of controls exposed |
Measures of Risk | Absolute Risk, Relative Risk, Odds Ratio, Attributable Risk | Absolute Risk, Relative Risk, Odds Ratio, Attributable Risk | Odds ratio and attributable Risk. |
Temporal Relationship between exposure and disease | Easy to establish | Sometimes hard to establish | Sometimes hard to establish |
Multiple Associations | Possible to study association of an exposure with several diseases | Possible to study association of an exposure with several diseases | Possible to study association of an exposure with several diseases |
Time required for the study | Generally, long because of need to follow-up the subjects | May be short | Relatively short |
Cost of study | Expensive | Generally, less expensive than prospective studies | Relatively inexpensive |
Population size needed | Relatively large | Relatively large | Relatively small |
Potential Bias | Assessment of outcome | Susceptible to bias both in assessment of exposure and assessment of outcome | Assessment of exposure |
Best when | Exposure is rare, disease is frequent among exposed | Exposure is rare, disease is frequent among exposed | Disease is rare and exposure is frequent among persons with disease |
Problems | Selection of nonexposed comparison group often difficult. Changes over time in criteria and methods. | Selection of nonexposed comparison group often difficult. Changes over time in criteria and methods. | Selection of appropriate controls often difficult. Incomplete information on exposure. |