Skip to main content
Future Healthcare Journal logoLink to Future Healthcare Journal
. 2023 Nov;10(Suppl 3):63. doi: 10.7861/fhj.10-3-s63

Assessment of the quality, content, and reliability of the information in CoMICs videos in comparison to YouTube videos on diabetes mellitus and PCOS

Shams Ali Baig A, Anagh Josh Banerjee A, Fazna Rahman A, Syeda Sabbah Batul A, Mukunth Kowsik A, Khushi Kumar A, Mohammed Faraaz Saiyad A, Vardhan Venkatesh A, Pranav Vishwanath Iyer A, Punith Kempegowda B
PMCID: PMC10884683  PMID: 38406716

Introduction

Concise Medical Information Cines (CoMICs) creates video infographics on various diseases tailored towards medical students and healthcare professionals (HCPs).

Diabetes and polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) are highly prevalent conditions and the importance of online resources for HCPs has become apparent. YouTube is a widely used resource regarding these conditions for both patients and HCPs; however, not all the videos offer accurate information and can sometimes be misleading.

The study aimed to assess YouTube videos about diabetes and PCOS targeted at patients and HCPs and compare these with the quality, content and reliability of CoMICs on the same topics.

Materials and methods

Videos relating to diabetes and PCOS were screened using agreed search terms and filtered using inclusion and exclusion criteria. A total of 124 videos, including the videos published by CoMICs, were finalised and each video was analysed using the DISCERN, JAMA, and GQS tools by two independent reviewers.

Results

In general, CoMICs videos scored higher if not the same in DISCERN, JAMA, and GQS in both diabetes and PCOS videos. Notably, in the DISCERN analysis, CoMICs videos on PCOS scored the highest in this section with a mean total score of 25.4+/-2.6 over the questions that assessed reliability. In contrast, YouTube videos on PCOS scored 19.1+/-3.9 and the You and Your Hormones video scored 19.

Conclusions

CoMICs was shown to provide more accurate and reliable results than its counterparts on YouTube and is a reliable source of medical information on diabetes and PCOS for patients and HCPs.


Articles from Future Healthcare Journal are provided here courtesy of Royal College of Physicians

RESOURCES