Skip to main content
. 2024 Feb 22;25(2):bbae030. doi: 10.1093/bib/bbae030

Table 4.

Over Enhancers strength prediction dataset and its independent test set performance comparison of Proposed and existing frameworks in terms of 4 evaluation measures

5-Fold Indepencent
framework ACC Sn Sp MCC ACC Sn Sp MCC
Weak/ Strong Enhancer EnhancerPred [31] 62.06 62. 67 61.46 0.24 55 45 65 0.1021
iEnhancer-2L [33] 61.93 62.21 61.82 0.24 60.5 47 74 0.2181
iEnhancer-EL [43] 65.03 69 61.05 0.31 61 54 68 0.2222
iEnhancer-Deep [16] 80.86 83.57 78.16 0.62 61 73 49 0.2266
iEnhancer-XG [45] 66.74 74.94 58.55 0.33 63.5 70 57 0.272
iEnhancer-EBLSTM [74] - - - - 65.8 81.2 53.6 0.324
iEnhancer-ECNN [75] - - - - 67.8 79.1 56.4 0.368
tan2019ensemble [44] 58.96 79.65 38.28 0.19 - - - -
Tan et al. Enhancer [44] 59 80 38 0.2 68.49 0.83 0.46 0.31
iEnhancer-DSNet [2] 63 63 67 0.26 83 83 67 0.70
Rank-GAN [51] 69.7 70.68 68.89 0.3954 69.7 70.68 68.89 0.3954
iEnhacner-BERT [47] 65.3 - - 0.31 70.1 0.401
iEnhancer-5Step [37] 68.1 75.53 60.8 0.37 - - - -
Enhancer-RD [36] - - - - 70.5 84 57 0.426
iEnhancer-GAN [36] - - - - 74.9 96.1 53.7 0.505
iEnhancer-CNN [65] 76.43 73.64 76.8 0.45 75 65.25 76.1 0.3232
iEnhancer-DCLA [52] 83.3 89.27 77.33 0.6736 78 87 69 0.5693
iEnhancer-MRBF [53] 76.95 77.23 79.69 0.5419 83.50 100.00 67.00 0.7098
Proposed 90 90 89.6 0.8 87.5 87.3 75 0.774