Skip to main content
. 2023 Dec 7;4(1):3–24. doi: 10.1021/acsmeasuresciau.3c00052

Table 2. Comparison of CL, ECL, and FL Microscopic Techniques for Detection/Imaging of Single Particles.

technique capabilities shortcomings remarks for future development ref
CL microscopy Imaging of single particles; study of structure–activity relationships; tracking/ visualizing single microswimmers; single bead based (bio)analysis Limited photon flux (low CL quantum yield); low light emission level of single particles; poor control over CL reactions; require a CL nanoemitter/ luminophore Efficiency of CL microscopy could be enhanced by designing/ developing highly emissive particles, bright/ tunable chemiluminescent molecules (probes), effective microscopic configurations/ set-ups, and highly sensitive light collection tools (26, 29, 38, 39, 49, 81)
ECL microscopy Determination of the structure-dependent electrocatalytic activities of single nanocatalysts; Imaging of the facet-dependent heterogeneities of single particles; stochastic collision electrochemistry; visualization/ monitoring of catalytic reactivities (e.g., HER, OER) of single NPs; single bead (bio)analysis Require an ECL luminophore/ nanoemitter; low ECL efficiencies of single particles Performance/applicability of ECL microscopy could be further improved in electrocatalysis and visualization of individual particles/molecules reactions by designing/ developing strong nanocatalysts, highly effective and stable nanoemitters/ luminophores, and using highly sensitive light emission collection tools; moreover, super-resolution ECL microscopy could improve the resolution limits for visualizing single particle/molecule reactions (27, 46, 48, 76, 8287)
FL microscopy Study nanocatalysis (e.g., photoelectrocatalysis, electrocatalysis) of single NPs/molecules; imaging, sensing, and tracking of fluorescent nanomaterials; collision/oxidation of single NPs; single molecule sensitivity; single bead (bio)analysis Usually suffered from photobleaching; limited availability of fluorescent dyes; require a fluorophore Synthesis/discovery of new fluorescent particles/molecules, electrode surface modification with highly catalytic materials, transduction of suitable FL systems with (electro)chemical approaches, and capacity to study nonfluorescent reactions could further extend/improve the applications of FL microscopy; more importantly, super-resolution FL microscopy could further expand resolution limits for studying individual particles reactions (6, 20, 44, 8895)