Skip to main content
. 2024 Feb 6;24(4):1069. doi: 10.3390/s24041069

Table 3.

Summary of the most important properties for piezoelectric and triboelectric nanogenerators [16].

Piezoelectric Nanogenerator Triboelectric Nanogenerator
Materials [175] BaTiO3 and P(VDF-TrFE), AlN, polymer threads,
ZnO nanowires and nanorods,
PZT nanowires and ceramic,
PVDF, PVDF-NaNbO3,
PVDF polymer and nanofibers,
Ceramic PMNZT,
PTFE and Al,
Al wires and PDMS
PTFE, FEP, PET, PDMS
Metals—Cu, Al, Ni,
Graphene
Nitrile, silicone,
Kapton film,
PLGA-PCL,
Silk fibroin, cellulose, chitin,
Rice paper, egg white
Structure [176] Spiral twining/multilayer/winding
Coaxial
Core-sheath
Woven (2D and 3D)
Twisted
Sandwich
E-skin
Nanofiber stacking/embedded
Coaxial
Core-shell
Knitted/woven (2D and 3D)
Textile, fibre, yarn
3D printed
Sandwich
E-skin
Output
performance
Pulse sensor 97.5 V; 1.16 µA [177] 109 V; 2.73 µA [19]
E-skin 3.2 V; 56.1 nA [133] 220 V; 1.12 µA [178]
Cardiac pacemaker 3.5 mV; 60 nA [179] 136 V; 2 µA [165]
Material
fabrication process
  • Complex and expensive fabrication process

  • Ceramics are fragile and brittle

  • +

    Wide selection of materials

  • +

    Relatively low cost

  • +

    Easily fabricated

Power density
  • +

    High power density

  • Lower current density

  • Affected by operation frequency

  • +

    High power density

  • +

    Higher output voltage

  • +

    Multiple-operation mode

Sensing performance
  • +

    High dynamic sensing

  • +

    Fast response

  • Poor static sensing

  • +

    Wide sensing range

  • +

    Fast response

  • Poor static sensing

Scalability
  • +

    Successfully miniaturized

  • Expensive and fragile

  • +

    Large-area application

  • Low-output voltage after miniaturization

Durability
  • +

    Good mechanical durability

  • +

    Good stability of electrical signal

  • Poor mechanical performance

  • High erosion of the material

  • Sensitive to environment

Biocompatibility
  • +

    (Co)polymers and lead-free materials are biocompatible

  • Ceramics can be toxic

  • +

    Biocompatible