Skip to main content
. 2024 Mar 5;2024(3):CD007491. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007491.pub3
Quality of life/health status
Study Outcomes Results Notes
Admission avoidance quality of life
Corwin 2005 SF 36
Physical functioning
Role physical
Pain SF 36
Physical functioning
Day 3
T= 37 (29.1), C= 41 (28.3)
Mean difference ‐1.9, 95% CI ‐10.7 to 6.9
Day 6
T=50.7 (33.7), C=50.9 (31.6)
Mean difference ‐5.2, 95% CI ‐13.7 to 3.2

Role physical
Day 3
T= 5.4 (18.8), C=5.5 (19.7)
Mean difference ‐1.8 95% CI ‐13.1 to 9.4
Day 6
T=21.1 (36.9), C=18.4 (36.5)
Mean difference 2.2, 95% CI ‐10.7 to 15.1

Pain
Day 3
T=57 (28.8), C=55.9 (25.4)
Mean difference ‐2.5 95% CI ‐10.1 to 5.1
Day 6
T=69.8 (26.4), C=64.8 (25.6)
Mean difference ‐3.8 95% CI ‐10.6 to 3.0 Differences calculated on absolute differences between day 0 & day 3, or day 0 & day 6.
Numbers vary due to missing data
(high score=better health)
Echevarria 2018 EQ‐5D‐5L utility 14 day
EQ‐5D‐5L utility 90 day
EQ‐5D‐5L utility (SD), mean 14 day unit change from baseline
T = 0.091 (0.249)
C = 0.055 (0.316)
EQ‐5D‐5L utility (SD), mean 90 day unit change from baseline
T = 0.003 (0.287)
C = 0.007 (0.338)
 
Mendoza 2009 SF 36
Physical component
Mental component
Physical component
T= 3.6 (‐0.5 to 7.7), C= 2.2 (‐1.9 to 6.4), P = 0.47
Mental component
T= 4.0 (‐0.9 to 8.9), C= 2.8 (‐2.4 to 8.0), P = 0.38
Score at 1 year (adjusted for baseline differences)
Ricauda 2008 Nottingham Health Profile 6 months, mean (SD)
T= 3.6 (7.9), C= 0.8 (4.5), P = 0.04
Changes at 6 months
Richards 2005 SF‐12 Mean physical and mental component score Physical component
At 2 weeks
T= 38.1, C= 40.2, P = 0.45
At 6 weeks
T= 42.2, C=45.8, P = 0.18

Mental component
At 2 weeks
T=48.3, C=48.6, P = 0.91
At 6 weeks
T = 50.4, C=51.0, P = 0.81
higher score=better health
Shepperd 2021 Health status EQ‐5D‐5L utility
Barthel Index
Mean EQ‐5D‐5L utility 6 months (SD)
T = 0.451 (0.324)
C = 0.457 (0.340)
Difference in means (95% CI)
‐0.006 (‐0.053, 0.041)
Mean (SD) Barthel Index at 6 months
T = 15.8 (4.4)
C = 15.6 (4.9)
Adjusted mean difference (95% CI)
0.24 (‐0.33, 0.80)
P=0.41
 
Talcott 2011 Quality of life EORTC QLQ C‐30 Role Function
T= 0.58, C= 0.78, P = 0.05
Emotional Function
T= 3.27, C= ‐6.94, P = 0.04
Quality of life data were collected at the time of consent to join the study, as soon as possible after the resolution of the episode.
Data were collected for the first study episode.
Change score
Tibaldi 2009 Nottingham Health Profile 6 months, mean (SD)
T= +1.09 (2.57), C= +0.18 (1.94), P = 0.046
 
Wilson 1999 Sickness Impact Profile (SIP)
Euroqol SIP, median (IQR)
T= 24 (20‐31), C= 26 (20‐31)
Difference ‐2 (95% CI ‐4 to 4), P = 0.73

Euroqol, median
T= 0.64, C= 0.63
Difference 0.01 (95% CI ‐0.12 to 0.09), P = 0.94 At 3 months follow‐up