Skip to main content
. 2023 Oct 13;11:598. Originally published 2022 Jun 1. [Version 2] doi: 10.12688/f1000research.111998.2

Table 4. WOMAC meta-analysis results.

WOMAC, Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Arthritis Index.

Study or subgroup Experimental Control Weight Std. Mean Difference
Mean SD Total Mean SD Total IV, Random, 95% CI
Chen et al., 2021 8.19 1.87 16 12.13 3.2 16 11.1% -1.47 [-2.26, -0.67]
Gomiero et al., 2017 30.6 3.18 32 29.0 2.86 32 14.6% 0.52 [0.02, 1.02]
Jahanjoo et al., 2019 22.07 1.29 30 21.17 1.24 30 14.3% 0.70 [0.18, 1.22]
Kelley Fitzerald et al., 2011 20.3 2.1 91 19.9 1.9 92 16.9% 0.20 [-0.09, 0.49]
Ojoawo et al., 2016 10.14 11.48 23 17.67 8.66 22 13.3% -0.73 [-1.33, -0.12]
Tunay et al., 2010 5.45 3.76 30 5.69 2.84 30 14.5% -0.07 [-0.58, 0.44]
Xiao et al., 2020 20.7 8.7 40 18.8 7.4 45 15.4% 0.23 [-0.19, 0.66]
Total (95% CI) 262 267 100.0% -0.02 [-0.44, 0.40]

Heterogeneity: Tau 2 = 0.25; Chi 2 = 31.26, df = 6 (p < 0.0001); I 2 = 81%.

Test for overall effect: Z = 0.11 (p = 0.91).