Table 4.
Ref | Participants Risk of bias |
Study | Ethnicity | Breast milk collection timing | Effects on breast milk content |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Observational studies | |||||
Castro, 2014 | Lactating mothers Chile, 2–4 months PP Obs Fair quality 7 |
Participants from Arica (n 24) and southern Santiago (n 11) completed questionnaires on health status, food habits and breast-feeding practices. BM As, B, Cd, caesium, Ca, Fe, Pb, Li, Mn, Se, U, V and Zn measured | Not provided | BM collected during the morning | No difference in essential and toxic element levels between groups, except B (P < 0·001) and Li (P < 0·05), which were higher in Arica. Caesium was higher in Santiago samples (P < 0·05). Pb positively associated with Fe and Zn (r = 0·60, r = 0·61, respectively, both P < 0·05), but inversely associated with Ca (r = −0·61, P < 0·05). As associated with Fe (r = 0·6, P < 0·05), and B and Ca (r = 0·54, P < 0·05) |
Dewailly, 1994 | Lactating healthy Inuit women < 3 d PP Artic Quebec Obs Poor quality 2 |
Inuit (n 109) participants. Seven PCB and chlorinated pesticides determined in BM and compared with Quebec Caucasian women. | Inuit | Not provided | Mean levels of the different analysed PCB were 3–7 times higher in BM from Inuit v. Caucasian women. Seafood consumption was extremely high for Inuit women, at 300 g/d compared with 12 g/d for Caucasian women |
Gundacker, 2002 | Healthy lactating mothers < 1 month PP Austria Obs Good quality 8 |
Urban (n 59) and rural (n 47) participants completed questionnaire about dietary habits, smoking, living area and dental filings. | Not provided | Not provided | Low Hg and Pb concentrations were far below currently recommended safety limits (Hg: mean = 1·59 g/l, sd = 1·21 g/l, n 116; Pb: mean = 1·63 g/l, sd = 1·66 g/l, n 138). Hg was significantly associated with area of residence, prematurity, cereal consumption and vitamin supplementation, whereas for Pb it was area of residence, fish consumption and smoking, all P < 0·05 |
Leotsinidis, 2005 | Healthy lactating mothers 3 d PP Greece Obs Fair quality 6 |
BM samples collected (n 180) to measure Cd and Pb at 3 and 14 d PP, FFQ | Not provided | Morning milk 2 h after previous breast-feeding | Mean (sd) values of colostrum samples: Cd, 0·190 (0·150) µg/l; Pb, 0·48 (0·60) µg/l. Higher BM lead in samples from urban areas, dietary habits seem to play a role in metal levels in human milk |
Ursinyova, 2018 | Healthy lactating mothers 6 weeks PP Slovakia Obs Good quality 7 |
n 142 participants asked about dietary habits, including frequency and amount of fish consumption per d | Not provided | Hand expression, no information on timing | Total Hg mean = 0·376 µg/l, sd = 0·475 µg/l, with no difference between fish and non-fish eaters. Negative association between BM total Hg and freshwater fish consumption (β = −0·193, P = 0·017) |
Obs, observational study; PP, postpartum; BM, breast milk; PCB, polychlorinated biphenyls.