Skip to main content
. 2024 Mar 7;14(3):e11092. doi: 10.1002/ece3.11092

TABLE 3.

Extensions of our proposed models from homogeneous classification process studies done by Spiers et al. (2022) and Wright et al. (2020).

Author Model framework Link to our model
Wright et al. (2020) and the models their proposed framework generalises such as Chambert et al. (2015), Chambert, Grant, et al. (2018) and Chambert, Waddle, et al. (2018)
Ecological process: absolute counts
zjsBernoulliψjs
Vjks|zjs=1Poissonλjks

Ecological process: relative abundance

Assume no occupancy sub‐model and for each individual, then VjksCategoricalλjks/jλjks

Observation process:

Yjks|Vjks=vjks,zjs=1Multinomialvjks|Ωjk, where ΩjkDirichletα

Observation process:

Yijs|Vijs=vjksCategoricalΩjks, where Ωjks can be chosen as any of the homogeneous models described in Table 2

Spiers et al. (2022) Ecological process: occupancy dynamics and encounter rates
zjstBernoulliψjst
VjistCategoricalλjistzjstjλjistzjst;

Ecological process: relative abundance

Choose t=1 and ignore the occupancy sub‐model.

VjisCategoricalλjissλjis;
Classification process: Yjis|VjisCategoricalΩjk, where ΩjkDirichletα Classification process: Yjis|Vjis=1CategoricalΩjks, where Ωjks can be chosen as any of the homogeneous models described in Table 2

Note: The table specifies the ecological process model for Wright et al. (absolute abundance model), Spiers et al. (occupancy dynamics and encounter rate model) and ours (relative abundance model); and also the observation model for Wright et al. and Spiers et al. (homogeneous classification process with classification probabilities simulated from Dirichlet distribution) and ours from heterogeneous models described in Table 2. Since our framework extends the work done by (Wright et al., 2020), it is safe to say that the classification component of our proposed framework are also generalised forms of Chambert et al. (2015), Chambert, Grant, et al. (2018) and Chambert, Waddle, et al. (2018). The index j refers to the true state identity, k refers to the reported state identity, s refers to the location in Spiers et al. (2022) and Wright et al. (2020) but refers to individuals in this study, i refers to the visit, and t refers to the year. In addition, the random variable Y refers to the reported observations, V to the verified observations and z to the occupancy state of the individuals.