Table 2.
Author/s & date (Location) |
Study design | Participant characteristics | Outcome measures (Demographics, risk factors, protective factors) |
Self-harm definition &measure | Key findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Arcelus et al. (2016) [11] (UK) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 268 Natal female: 45.2% Natal male: 50.7% Did not answer: 4.1% Age range: 17–25 years (M = 19.9) |
Demographics Psychopathology: SCL-90; Self-esteem: RSE; Transphobia victimisation: Experiences of Transphobia Scale; Interpersonal functioning: IIP-32; Social support: MSPSS |
NSSI: SIQ |
|
Almazan et al. (2021) USA) [33] |
Cross-sectional |
n = 27,715 Trans woman: 38.3% Trans man: 29.1% Nonbinary: 30.2% Cross-dresser: 2.5% 18+ (not provided) |
Demographics Severe psychological distress: K-6; Past-month binge alcohol use & past year tobacco smoking: all 1-item |
Past-year suicide ideation & suicide attempt measure not provided |
|
Andrew et al. (2020) [34] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 155 Non-binary: 25.2% (no further breakdown provided) AFAB: 75.5% Age range not provided (M = 29.86) |
Demographics Trauma exposure: Life Events Checklist; Nightmares: Trauma-Related Nightmare Survey; PTSD: PTSD checklist for DSM-5 |
Suicide risk: SBQ-R |
|
Austin et al. (2022) [35] (USA & Canada) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 372 Trans man: 89.2% Non-binary/gender fluid: 32.8% Man: 9.4% Trans Woman: 11.6% Woman: 3.2% Demiboy: 1.1% Transgender: 0.3% Other: 0.8% Two-Spirit: 05% * NB these categories are not mutually exclusive* 14–18 years (M = 15.99) |
Demographics LGBTQ-related stigma: 5-items from NHAI; Interpersonal & environmental LGBTQ microaggressions: Interpersonal LGBTQ Microaggressions subscale & Environmental LGBTQ Microaggressions subscale (adapted from LGBQ Microaggressions On-Campus Scale) |
Suicidality: 2-items from DSM-5 |
|
Azeem et al. (2019) [36] (Pakistan) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 156 Transgender Age range not provided (M = 39.26) |
Demographics Depression: Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression Self-reported family income, illicit substance use and smoking: measures not provided |
SI: Scale for Suicide Ideation |
|
Barboza et al. (2016) [37] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 350 Transgender MTF: 62% FTM: 35% Age range not provided |
Demographics Victimisation: 2 items; Substance use: 1 item covering 10 illicit substances; Family social support & Counselling or psychotherapy use: both 1-item |
Suicidal Risk: 2 items |
|
Basar & Oz (2016) [38] (Turkey) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 116 Trans men: 75.9% Trans women: 24.1% Median: 25-years |
Demographics Discrimination: PDS; Depression: BDI Resilience: RSA; Social support: MSPSS |
Suicide attempt history; NSSI: ascertained by clinical interview |
|
Bauer et al. (2016) [21] (Canada) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 380 Transgender MTF: 52.6% FTM: 47.4% 16+ (M = 32.7) |
Demographics Chronic illness/pain, immigration history, religious upbringing, childhood abuse & mental health disorders: self-reported; Transphobia: Experiences of Transphobia Scale; Transphobic harassment & violence; medical transition status, hormone use, social transition status, being perceived as cisgender: self-reported; Social support: Medical Outcomes Study Social Support Scale |
Past year suicide ideation & attempts: dichotomous scale |
|
Brennan et al. (2017) [39] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 83 Trans women/MTF: 40% Trans men/FTM: 29% Various gender nonconforming identities: 31% 19–70 years (Not provided) |
Demographics Depression: CES-D; Anxiety: Becks Anxiety Inventory; Gender Minority Stress: GMSR |
Suicide ideation, suicide attempts & NSSI: dichotomous scale |
|
Becerra et al. (2021) [40] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 1369 Transgender 18+ (Not provided) |
Demographics Psychological distress: K-6; Abuse/violence: 4-items; Partner abuse/violence: 24-items: Harassment/abuse due to bathroom use: 3-items |
SI & SA: 4 questions with Y/N responses |
|
Bosse et al. (2023) [41] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 286 Transgender and Nonbinary 18–25 years (M = 21.5) |
Demographics Parental acceptance-rejection: Parental Acceptance-Rejection Questionnaire; Sibling acceptance-rejection: Elder Sibling Acceptance-Rejection Questionnaire; Depression: CES-D |
Suicidality: 1 item for suicide ideation, planning & attempts |
|
Budhwani et al. (2018) [42] (Dominican Republic) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 298 Transgender women Age range not provided (M = 26) |
Demographics Sexual abuse, psychological abuse, torture, attempt on own life by another: dichotomous Y/N; Depression: 1 item; Illicit drugs: Dichotomous Y/N (in past 6-months); Income & education level: self-report |
Suicide attempts: dichotomous Y/N |
|
Burish et al. (2022) [43] (USA & Canada) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 139 Transgender or nonbinary 18+ (M = 33.78) |
Demographics Gender Minority Stress: GMSR Social Support: Perceived Social Support Scale from Family & Friends Scale; Optimism: LOT-R; Body Acceptance & Congruence: Transgender Congruence Scale |
Suicidality: SBQ-R |
|
Busby et all. (2020) [44] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 868 (n = 86 identified as transgender) 18+ (Not provided) |
Demographics Depression: PHQ-9; Discrimination: EDS; Interpersonal Victimisation: Interpersonal Victimisation Scale-Revised; Social Connectedness: UCLA Loneliness Scale; LGBTQ Affirmation: 3-items from LGBTQ Identity Affirmation Scale (modified from original 12-item scale) |
Past year suicide ideation; lifetime suicide attempts; NSSI: 1 item from the Youth Risk Behavior Survey |
|
Campbell et al. (2023) [45] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 1078 gender-conversion treatment n = 24,192 control Transgender 11–17 years when gender conversion efforts began (Not provided) |
Demographics Gender conversion efforts: 1 item |
Suicide attempts: dichotomous Y/N & number of attempts |
|
Cerel et al. (2021) [46] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 2784 27.3% transgender female 27% transgender man 38.7% non-binary 1.2% transgender unspecified 5.7% transgender other 18+ (M = 34.35 suicide exposure; M = 31.33: no suicide death exposure) |
Demographics Suicide attempt exposure, support from family of origin, mental health diagnosis, being a POC, gender binary status & gender identity: all self-reported |
Past year suicide ideation & attempts: 4-items with dichotomous Y/N |
|
Chen et al. (2019) [47] (China) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 1309 Transgender men: n = 622 Transgender women: n = 687 Age range not provided (Transgender men M = 3.78; Transgender women M = 22.89; Overall M = 23.31) |
Demographics Feelings towards natal sex, seeking hormone therapy, seeking gender reassignment surgery, intense conflicts with parents regarding sexuality, discrimination or violence in public due to sexuality, childhood adversity (incl. Bullying and insults at school), Seeking MH support services & history of major depressive disorder: all measured using unspecified measures Depression: CESD-9; Self-esteem: RSE |
Self-harm, suicide ideation & suicide attempts measured using dedicated items (not specified) |
|
Chen et al. (2020) [48] (China) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 250 Transgender women 18+ (M = 27.9) |
Demographics Anxiety & depression: K-10 Discrimination (incl. Verbal abuse), mental health status, PTSD screening, access to mental health services, alcohol & drug use, physical abuse, harassment (restricted personal freedom, economic control due to gender identity), sexual violence: all dichotomous Y/N |
Suicide ideation & attempts: dichotomous Y/N |
|
Chinazzo et al. (2023) [49] (Brazil) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 213 Transgender boys/men: 48.6% Transgender girls/women: 20.8% Non-binary: 30.7% 13–25 years (M = 18.53) |
Demographics Depression: MDS; Discrimination: Lifetime & Daily Discrimination Subscale; Gender Distress: TYC-GDS; Socioeconomic Status: Deprivation Scale Social Support: MSPSS; Social Support relating to gender identity: 1 item; Gender Positivity: Gender Positivity Scale |
Suicide ideation & attempts: dichotomous Y/N |
|
Claes et al. (2015) [50] (UK) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 155 Transgender men: n = 52 Transgender women: n = 103 17–77 years (M = 34.52) |
Demographics Psychological Symptoms: SCL-90-R; Body Dissatisfaction: HBDS; Transphobia/victimisation: Experiences of Transphobia Scale; Interpersonal Problems: IIP-32 Perceived Social Support: MSPSS; Self-Esteem: RSE |
NSSI: SIQ |
|
Cogan et al. (2020) [51] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 155 Various gender identities 18–67 years (M = 29.86) |
Demographics Gender minority stress: GMSR; Traumatic experiences: Life Events Checklist for DSM-5 |
Suicide risk: SBQ-R |
|
Cogan et al. (2021a) [52] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 29.86 Various gender identities 18–67 years (M = 29.86) |
Demographics Traumatic experiences: Life Events Checklist; Gender Minority Stressors: GMSR |
Suicide risk: SBQ-R |
|
Cogan et al. (2021b) [53] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 29.86 Various gender identities 18–67 years (M = 29.9) |
Demographics Lifetime Trauma Exposure; LEC-5; Distal gender minority stressors: GMSR |
Suicide risk: SBQ-R |
|
Cramer et al. (2016) [54] (UK) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 27,658 Various gender identities 18+ (not provided) |
Demographics Interpersonal correlates (HRD: family rejection, childhood harassment, rejection, discrimination); HRD in workplace, healthcare settings, health insurance; TGD-related physical assault, lifetime TGD-related intimate partner abuse; sexual assault; connection to TGD community; family support & co-worker support: measures not specified |
Suicidal thoughts & behaviours: 4-items with dichotomous |
|
Davey et al. (2016) [55] (UK) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 97 Control: n = 97 60 Transgender women 37 Transgender men Control: 60 cisgender women 37 cisgender men Age range not provided (Transgender: M = 36.18; Control M = 37.16) |
Demographics, incl. Civil status, living situation TGD people were asked for treatment stage & hormone status; General Psychopathology: SCL-90-R Self-Esteem: RSE; Body Satisfaction: HBDS; Perceived Social Support: MSPSS |
NSSI: SIQ-TR |
|
de Graaf et al. (2020) [56] (Canada, UK, Netherlands) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 2771 Natal male: n = 937 Natal female: n = 1834 13+ (M = 15.99) |
Demographics, incl. age at assessment, year of assessment, full-scale IQ, parents' marital status, & parents' social class IQ: Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children & Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale; Parent social status/education: Hollingshead's Four-Factor Index of Social Status (non-validated scale); Items from the CBCL & YSR were used to measure desire to be the opposite sex, poor peer relations & behavioural problems |
Suicidality = Item 18 from CBCL & Item 91 from YSR |
|
dickey et al. (2015) [57] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 773 Various gender identities Age range not provided (M = 34.5) |
Demographics Depression & Anxiety: DASS-21; Feelings about body: BIS |
NSSI: ISAS |
|
Drescher et al. (2021) [58] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 70 Transgender men: 43.4% Transgender women: 25.7% 4 Non binary: 40% 18-65 (M = 29.97) |
Demographics Homelessness & perceptions about safety: 1-item (these were adapted from the LGBT Health & Services Needs in New York State study & Seattle LGBT Commission 2010 Needs Assessment Survey respectively) Physical violence & sexual violence victimisation: 3-items |
Suicidality (ideation & attempts): Dichotomous Y/N |
|
Drescher et al. (2023) [59] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 115 Transgender Non-conforming 18+ (M = 27.61) |
Demographic Depression: PHQ-9 Gender Minority Stressors/Resilience: GMSR Emotion Dysregulation; DERS-SF |
Suicide intent & risk: SHI |
|
Edwards et al. (2012) [60] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 106 Transgender women: 40.6% Transgender men: 32.1% Questioning: 7.5% Genderqueer: 2.8% Nonbinary/gender fluid: 1.9% Neutrois: 0.9% Trans: 0.9% Intersex: 0.9% Not provided: 12.3% 18–65 years (M = 29.17) |
Demographics Emotional Stability: Suicide Resiliency Inventory-25; Relational Support: Perceived Social Support from Family (PSS-FA) and Friends (PSS-FR) |
Suicide risk: SBQ-R |
|
Goldblum et al. (2018) [61] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 290 Transgender 18–65 years (M = 37.01) |
Demographics In-school gender-based victimisation: 2 items; Effect of gender-based victimisation: 1 item |
Suicide attempt history: 2-item |
|
Gower et al. (2018) [62] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 2168 Natal female: 68.1% Natal male: 31.9% No age range provided but USA grades 5, 8, 9, 11 (ages 10–18) (M not provided) |
Demographics Parent connectedness: 3-item scale not validated; Youth Development Opportunities: 7-item scale from Developmental Assets Profile; Teacher student engagement: 4-items from Student Engagement Inventory; Feeling safe in community: 2-item scale not validated; School safety: 1-item scale not validated; Depression: PHQ-2; Alcohol, drug, cigarette use in past 30 days: Dichotomous Y/N Single items measured how much you feel other adult relatives, friends, & adults in the community care about you |
Suicide ideation and attempts: Dichotomous Y/N |
|
Green et al. (2021) [63] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 11,914 Nonbinary: 63% Trans male: 29% Trans female: 8% 13–24 years (M = 17.62) |
Demographics Depression: PHQ; Victimisation, Receipt of puberty blockers, & exposure to GICE: all 1-item Gender-affirming hormone therapy: 3 items with binary responses; Parent support for gender identity: 2 items |
Suicidal thoughts & behaviours: 2 items from YRB survey |
|
Grossman & D'Augelli (2007) [64] (USA) |
Mixed methods |
n = 55 Trans female: n = 31 Trans male: n = 24 15–21 years (Trans female M = 17.5 Trans male M = 19.5) |
Demographics Relation between suicide attempts & TGD status: RHAI; Lethality of suicide attempt determined by interviewer using lethality rating scale; Childhood Gender Nonconformity: GCS; Childhood Parental Abuse: Child & Adolescent Psychological Abuse Measure Body Esteem: Body-Esteem Scale for Adolescents & Adults |
Suicide ideation: 3 items; Suicide attempts: Questions used in previous TGD suicide studies (cited) inc. whether drugs and/or alcohol was used at the time |
|
Grossman et al. (2016) [65] (USA) |
Longitudinal (First panel data) |
n = 129 MTF: n = 44 (34%) FTM: n = 44 (31%) MTDG: n = 14 (11%) FTDG: n = 31 (24%) 15–21 years (M = 18) |
Demographics Painful & provocative events components of IPTS: PPES |
Suicide ideation & attempts: 2 parts of SHBQ Suicide ideation components of IPTS: INQ Capacity for self-harm components of IPTS: ACSS |
|
Jackman et al. (2018) [13] (USA) |
Cross-sectional (quantitative in-person interviews with survey) |
n = 332 Transgender 16+ (M = 34.56) |
Demographics Enacted stigma: EDS Felt Stigma: SCS; Transgender congruence: TCS Family support of TGD identity: 1-item; Friend support: 4-items from MSPSS; TGD community connectedness: 5-item subscale from GMSR |
NSSI: SITBI |
|
Kaplan et al. (2017) [66] (Lebanon) |
Cross-sectional interview surveys |
n = 54 Trans females 18–58 years (M = 27) |
Demographics Depression: PHQ-& PHQ-9; General social support & social isolation: Items from Social Relationship Scale; Peer Support: 1-item regarding friends support of TGD identity; Gender identity openness: 2-items from RHS |
Suicide ideation: 4-items; Suicide attempts: 2-items |
|
Kaplan et al. (2020) [67] (Lebanon) |
Longitudinal |
n = 16 Trans women 22–50 years (Median = 26-years) |
Demographics Sexual health & behaviour: 11-items measuring STI history; 13-items assessing sexual risk behaviour; & 23-items measuring sexual relationship power; Mental Health (Anxiety & Depression): HADS; Depression: PHQ-9; PTSD: 4-item Primary Care PTSD Screen Family acceptance: 9-item measure of family acceptance; Lifetime trauma: 25-item Trauma History Questionnaire; Social Support: Social Cohesion Scale; GMSR & MDPSS; Gender affirmation, identity & expression: TGD specific Multigroup Ethnic Identity Measure, 6-items measuring gender typicality, & Outness Inventory; 31-items measuring desire/satisfaction of transition; 22-items measuring gender affirmation; 5-items measuring gender affirmation satisfaction; War exposure: War Event Questionnaire; Transphobia: 35-item scale (validated in population) |
Suicidality: (thoughts, plans, & attempts ever & in past 3 months): Dichotomous Y/N |
|
Klein & Golub (2016) [68] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 3458 Transgender & Nonconforming 19-98 (M = 36.69) |
Demographics Substance misuse: Dichotomous Y/N; Family rejection: 7-items |
Lifetime history of suicide attempts: Dichotomous Y/N |
|
Kota et al. (2020) [69] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 928 Trans women 18–65 years (M = 35) |
Demographics Perceived stigma: 4-items from RHM; Psychosocial impact of gender minority status: 4-items from TAIM; Depression: 6-items from BSI; Anxiety: 3-item subscale from BSI; Excessive drinking: 3-items; Non-inject drug use & Injection drug use: both 1-item; Intimate Partner Violence: 3-items; Sexual abuse: 3-items; Child Sexual Abuse: 1-item; HIV status: 1 item |
Suicide ideation: 2-items - 1 regards past-year suicide ideation & one whether this related to gender status |
|
Kuper et al. (2021) [70] (USA0 |
Cross-sectional |
n = 1896 Gender identity other than birth assigned sex: 78.1% AFAB 14-30 (M = −21.1) |
Demographics Gender related affirmation: 7-items; Gender-related self-concept: 7-items; Victimisation (Gender & Sexual Orientation-related): 6-items; Desire for gender-affirming medical care: 1-item; Depressive symptoms: PHQ-9; Social Support: Friend & family support: MSPSS; |
Past year suicide ideation, attempts & suicide risk: SBQ-R Past year suicide attempts: binary variable modified SBQ-R |
|
Leon et al. (2021) [71] (USA) |
Retrospective clinical data |
n = 185 AFAB: 86.6% AMAB: 13.4% 7–25 years (Median at clinic enrolment: 16.3; Median at most recent clinic visit: 18.6) |
Demographics Social transition; Medical transition; Mental health history (diagnoses, history of suicide ideation & attempts, psychiatric hospitalisation, history of abuse, bullying & victimisation) all captured from electronic medical records |
Documented in medical records |
|
Maguen et al. (2010) [72] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 153 Gender identity female: 25% Somewhat female: 20% Equally both: 25% Somewhat male: 24% Male: 6% 18+ (M = 47) |
Demographics Mental Health Treatment: 3 items; TGD-related verbal abuse & physical violence: 2 items; IV drug use: 1 item; |
Suicide attempts: Dichotomous Y/N & number of attempts |
|
Mak et al. (2020) [73] (USA) |
Retrospective medical record |
n = 6327 Trans men: 2875 (45%) Trans women: 3452 (55%) 3-45 (age groups: 3–17, 18–25, 26–35, 36–45, >45) |
Demographics Mental health diagnoses as stated on EMR: incl. anxiety disorders, ADHD disorders, ASD, bipolar disorders, depressive disorders, schizophrenia spectrum disorders, substance use/abuse, conduct/disruptive disorders, eating disorders, dementia, other psychoses, & personality disorders |
Suicide Attempts: Emergency Medical Records (as defined by ICD-9 or ICD10) Suicide Ideation: Binary variable: Ever or never |
|
Maksut et al. (2020) [74] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 381 Trans women 15-29 (not provided) |
Demographics Perceived, anticipated & enacted stigma (related to TGD status): Gender Identity Stigma Scale; Sexual behaviour stigma: Sexual Behavior Stigma Scale; Severe Psychological Distress: Kessler Scale |
Suicide ideation & attempts: 1-item each |
|
Marx et al. (2021) [75] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 610 Transgender & gender nonconforming 14–18 years (M = 15.81) |
Demographics Sexual victimisation: 1-item; Sexual harassment victimisation: 1-item; Bias-based peer victimisation: 1- item; Problematic drug use: 6-items Parental monitoring & support: 7-items; School belonging: 6-items |
Suicide ideation: 1-item |
|
Moody & Smith (2013) [76] (Canada) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 134 Man/boy: 37.6% Woman/girl: (37.6% Trans: 50.4% Transgender (51.1% Transexual/transsexual: 45.1% FTM: 27.1% MTF: 29.3% On FTM Spectrum:15% On MTF Spectrum:17.3% Genderqueer: 24.8% Two-spirit: 7.5% Transman: 24.8% Transwoman: 30.8%) Man of trans experience: 8.3% Woman of trans experience: 7.5% Androgyne: 8.3% Woman, boy, gender blender, bi-gender, polygender, pangender, cross-dresser, transvestite, intersexual, drag king: 30.4% Other (gender bent, third gender, gender fucker, trans woman):10.6% (participants may be in multiple categories) 18–75 years (M = 36.75) |
Demographics Optimist; LOT-R; Social support: PSS-FR & PSS-Fa; Suicide resilience: SRI-25; Reasons for living; RFL |
Suicidal behaviours: SBQ-R |
|
Parr & Howe (2019) [77] (USA) |
Mixed-methods (Cross-sectional survey data included in this review) |
n = 182 Trans female: n = 107 (26.6%)/Trans male: n = 75 (18.7)/genderqueer/GNC: n = 44 (10.9%)/Other: n = 48 (11.9%) 14–65 years (not provided) |
Demographics Identity nonaffirmation microaggression events: 3-items; Depression, acute sadness & loneliness: 2-items from SBQ-R |
Past-year suicide ideation & lifetime suicide ideation & attempts: 2-items from SBQ-R |
|
Perez-Brumer et al. (2015) [78] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 1229 Transgender: FTM n = 532; MTF n = 697 (but included multiple gender identities) Age & mean not provided |
Demographics Structural Stigma: 4-item composite index based on gender minority measure; Internalised Transphobia: Transgender Identity Survey |
Lifetime & past-year suicide attempts: 2-items |
|
Peterson et al. (2017) [26] (USA) |
Retrospective chart review |
n = 96 MTF: n = 54 MTF: n = 31 Gender fluid/nonbinary: n = 15 12–22 years (M = 17.1) |
Demographics Psychosocial assessment at outset appointment: drug/alcohol use; history of legal problems/arrest; gang involvement; involved in fights; history of being bullied; feel safe at home; interest in weight change: All dichotomous Y/N; Body image concerns: 1-item |
Suicide attempt history; cutting or self-injurious behaviour history: Dichotomous Y/N |
|
Rabasco & Andover [79] (2020) | Cross-sectional |
n = 96 Transgender woman: n = 71 Transgender man: n = 26 Gender nonconforming: n = 8 Gender queer: n = 9 Other: n = 19 12–22 years (M = 17.1) |
Demographics Minority stressors: GMSR; Gender Identity State Policy Score |
Suicide ideation: BSS |
|
Ross-Reed et al. (2019) [7] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 858 Natal male: n = 453 Natal female: n = 435 11–19 years (not provided) |
Demographics Sexual violence, dating violence, Dichotomous Y/N; Gender identity Y/N to either Cis or Gender Minority; 14 resiliency questions (family, peer, school, & community): 4-point Likert scale |
NSSI & past-year suicide attempts: Dichotomous y/N |
|
Russell et al. (2018) [44] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 129 Transgender Gender non-conforming 15–21 years (not provided) |
Demographics Depressive symptoms: BDI for Youth; Chosen Name Use: Whether preferred name was different from name given at birth; Are you able to go by your preferred name at home; school; work with friends Social Support: CASSS |
Suicidal Ideation & behaviour: SHBQ |
|
Scheim et al. (2020) [80] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 22,286 Trans woman: 35.6% Trans man: 33.1% Nonbinary AFAB: 25.5% Nonbinary AMAB: 5.8% 18+ (M = 30.9) |
Psychological Distress: K-6 Gender concordant identification: 1 item |
Suicide ideation: 3-items |
|
Seelman (2016) [81] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 2325 Trans male: 43.7% Trans female: 30.9% Gender nonconforming natal female:16.6% Gender nonconforming natal male: 2.2% Crossdresser male:4.7% Crossdresser female:1.9% 18–76 years (M = 31.02) |
Demographics, incl. disability status Generation (time period) when participant attended college & age in college; Denial of bathroom access in college; Gender-appropriate housing in college (due to trans status); Interpersonal victimisation: experience of harassment/bullying; physical assault/attack; sexual assault by teachers/staff at school/college due to trans status |
Lifetime suicide attempts: Dichotomous Y/N |
|
Snooks & McLaren (2020) [82] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 848 Trans men: n = 197 Trans women: n = 614 18–80 years (M = 26.27) |
Demographics Gender affirming surgery: Y/N/I'd rather not say; Interpersonal Needs: INQ-R; Depression: CES-D |
Suicidal thought & behaviours: SBQ-R |
|
Staples et al. (2018) [83] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 237 Gender identity other: 55.9% FTM: 24.6% MTF: 10.2% Nonbinary: 9.3% 18–44 years (M = 28) |
Demographics Distal TGD stress: Daily Heterosexist Experiences Questionnaire; Internalised TGD negativity; transgender identity scale (TGIS) |
Suicide ideation: BSS; NSSI: DSHI |
|
Strauss et al. (2019) [84] (Australia) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 859 Transgender Gender diverse 14–25 years (M = 19.37) |
Demographics Depressive Symptoms: PHQ-A; Anxiety: GAD-7; Self-reported psychiatric diagnoses, exposure to negative experiences, peer rejection, issues with educational setting, issues with accommodation, bullying, body dysphoria, discrimination, employment issues, experiencing significant loss, isolation from TGD people, isolated from services, helping others with mental health, lack of family support |
Self-reported adverse health outcomes (incl. self-harm, suicidal thoughts & attempts - lifetime and past-year |
|
Strauss et al. (2020) [85] (Australia) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 859 Transgender Gender diverse: 29.7% Trans men/men: 15% Trans women/women: 48.5% various nonbinary identities (incl. nonbinary trans masc, nonbinary transfemme, agender, bigender, pangender, and others) 14–25 years (M = 19.37) |
Demographics Depressive symptom: PHQ-A (for adolescents); Anxiety: GAD-7; Self-reported psychiatric diagnoses: range of diagnoses listed (e.g., PTSD, eating disorders, substance use disorders) & n selected those which had received formal diagnoses; Exposure to abuse: various questions about negative experiences associated with poor mental health - 6 items |
Self-harm & suicidal behaviours (self-harm ideation, self-harm, reckless behaviour endangering life, suicide ideation & suicide attempts): 5 items (3-point scale) |
|
Suen et al. (2018) [86] (Hong Kong) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 106 Assigned male at birth: 63.2% Assigned female at birth: 38.8% 25->44 years (not provided) |
Demographics Satisfaction with relationship status: Y/N; Quality of Life: 1-item- 6-point scale |
Suicidality: 4-point scale -"never thought of suicide", “have had thoughts of suicide", “have often had thoughts of suicide", “have attempted suicide" |
|
Taliaferro et al. (2018) [87] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 2168 Transgender, genderqueer, genderfluid, or unsure about gender identity AMAB: 31.5% AFAB: 67.2% AFAB Declined to answer: 1.2% School grades 5, 8, 9, & 11 were given. These ages are 10–16 years (not provided) |
Demographics Gender identity: Y/N beside relevant gender identity; Depressive Symptoms: PHQ-2; Gender- based bullying/victimisation (2-items); Physical bullying/victimisation: 1-item Parent connectedness: 3-items; Teacher/school adult relationships: Student Engagement Instrument: Friend caring: 1-item; Connectedness to non-parental adults: 2-items; School safety: item |
Past year NSSI: How many times? >10 = repetitive |
|
Taliaferro et al. (2019) [88] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 1635 Transgender or gender nonconforming: AMAB: 32% AFAB: 68.1% 14/15 years & 16/17 years (not provided) |
Demographics Assigned sex & gender identity: 2-items; Family substance use: 2-items; Physical health problems & mental health problems: both 1-item; Positive screen for depression: 2-items; Physical or sexual abuse: 3-items; Relationship violence, witness to family violence & teasing: all 2-items; Bullying: 4-items; running away, violence perpetrator, skipped school, cigarette smoking, alcohol use, binge drinking: all 1-item Parent connectedness: 3-items; connectedness to other adults: 2-items; school engagement & teacher/school adult relationships: both 6-items; neighbourhood safety: 2-items; prescription drug misuse: 4-items; illegal drug use: 5-items; multiple sexual partners: 2-items; bullying perpetrator: 4-items; friend caring, sport participation, involvement in school activities, religious activities, physical activity, school plans, academic achievement, school safety: all 1-item |
NSSI: 2-Item scale - 1 asking about past year NSSI engagement & how many times Suicide attempts: Ever attempted suicide, in past year, or no |
|
Tebbe & Moradi (2016) [89] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 353 Transgender (trans women, trans men, non-binary) 18–66 years (M = 25.21) |
Demographics Prejudice & discrimination: DHEQ: Internalised antitrans attitudes: IHS; Fear of antitrans stigma: Gender-Related Fears subscale of Transgender Adaptation & Integration Measure; Drug use: Brief DAST; Alcohol use: AUDIT; Depressive symptoms: CES-D Social Support: Family, Friend, & Significant Other subscale of MSPSS |
Suicide risk: SBQ-R |
|
Testa et al. (2012) [90] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 271 Tran women: n = 179 Trans men: n = 92 18–69 years (M = 37) |
Demographics Physical violence: 1 item, then 1 item regarding how many times these were gender-identity related; Sexual violence: 1 item, then 1 item regarding how many times these were gender-identity related; Alcohol abuse: Dichotomous Y/N; Illicit substance use: Dichotomous Y/N |
Suicide ideation & attempts: Dichotomous Y/N & how many times |
|
Testa et al. (2017) [91] (USA & Canada) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 816 Trans man; Trans woman; female to different gender; male to different gender; Intersex 18+ (M = 32.53) |
Demographics External & internal gender minority stress: GMSR; Belongingness & perceived burdensomeness: INQ-121 |
Past year suicide ideation: SIS; Lifetime suicide ideation: 1-item; Lifetime suicide attempts: SA: 1-item |
|
Toomey et al. (2018) [92] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 1773 Trans female: n = 202 Trans male: n = 175 Nonbinary: n = 344 Questioning: n = 1052 11–19 years (M = 14.7) |
Demographics including highest parental education level, urbanicity, & gender identity | Lifetime suicide behaviour: Dichotomous Y/N 1-item: “Have you ever tried to kill yourself?" |
|
Treharne et al. (2020) [93] (Aotearoa/New Zealand & Australia) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 700 (TGD: n = 293; cisgender; n = 308) 18–74 years (M = 30) |
Demographics Discrimination: EDS; Psychological Distress: K-10 Perceived social support: MSPSS; Resilience: BRS |
Suicidal ideation: SIDAS Suicide ideation & attempts: Series of single items about suicidality; Self-harm: DSHI |
|
Trujillo et al. (2017) [94] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
N = 78 Transmen: 33.3% Transwomen: 37.2% Another gender:29.5% 18+ (not provided) |
Demographics Anti-trans discrimination: HHRDS; Depression & Anxiety: HSCL-25 Perceived social support: MSPSS |
Suicidality: SBQ |
|
Turban et al. (2019) [95] (USA, incl. Guam, American Samoa, & Puerto Rico & military bases) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 27,715 Crossdresser: 2.6% Trans woman: 63.4% Trans man: 21.1% Nonbinary/genderqueer AFAB: 8.5% Nonbinary/genderqueer AMAB: 4.5% 18->65 years (M = 31.2) |
Demographics Lifetime exposure to GICE: binary Y/N; Experiencing GICE <10yrs; Binge Drinking during past month: >1 -day consuming >5 alcoholic drinks; Cigarette & illicit drug use (excl. marijuana); Psychological distress: K-10 |
Suicide ideation I in past year/SA requiring inpatient hospitalisation in past year; Lifetime suicide ideation & attempts |
|
Veale et al. (2017) [15] (Canada) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 923 Trans girls/women Trans boys/men Nonbinary AFAB Nonbinary AMAB 14–25 years (Not provided) |
Demographics Enacted stigma: Enacted Stigma Index; Stress: Single items from General Wellbeing Schedule School connectedness: School Connectedness Scale; Family Connectedness: 7-items (non-validated); 19–25 yr olds were given 8-item Parent Connectedness Scale; Friend Support: 1-item; Social Support: 19–25 yr olds: Medical Outcomes Study Social Support Survey |
Suicidality: NSSI, suicide ideation & attempts: Dichotomous Y/N |
|
Veale et al. (2021) [96] (Aotearoa/New Zealand) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 610 Trans and nonbinary 14–83 years (M = 32.1) |
Demographics GICE: 1-item; Mental Health: K10; Family rejection: GMSR (1-item); Internalised transphobia: 3-items from Gender Identity Self-Stigma Scale |
NSSI, suicide ideation & attempts: using questions from the NZ Youth 2000 series: No to more than 5 times (5-point scale) |
|
Wang et al. (2021) [97] (China) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 1293 Transgender & gender queer 13–29 years (M = 21.93) |
Demographics Depression: CESD-9; Anxiety: GAD-7; Presence or absence of parental psychological abuse; Self-esteem: RES |
Suicide & self-harm risk: 4-items |
|
Woodford et al. (2018) [98] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 214 Transgender 18+ (M = 22.83) |
Demographics LGBTQ interpersonal microaggressions & victimisation on campus (frequency): 7-items incl. bathroom use & being referred to as old/natal gender; Victimisation: Sexual Orientation Victimisation Questionnaire |
Suicide attempts: 1-item |
|
Yadegarfard et al. (2014) [99] (Thailand) |
Cross-sectional (between groups) |
n = 260 Trans women: n = 129 Cis men: n = 131 15–25 years (M = 20) |
Demographics Family Rejection: 6-item measure designed for this study (no measure exists); Social Isolation: SSA; Loneliness: ICLA Loneliness Scale-Short; Depression: DASS-21 (short version); Sexual Risk Behaviour: ‘series of questions' |
Suicidal thoughts & attempts: PANSI |
|
Yockey et al. (2020) [100] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 790 Transgender 18+ (not provided) |
Demographics Interpersonal Violence: Y/N; Lifetime substance use (cigarettes, alcohol, vaping, & prescription drugs): 4-items Y/N |
Suicidal Behaviours 3-items Y/N |
|
Yockey et al. (2022) [101] (USA) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 27,715 Transgender, nonbinary, genderqueer and others 18+ (not provided) |
Demographics Psychological victimisation and harassment: 1 item Y/N; Family support: 1-item 3-point scale |
Past year suicide ideation: 1- item Y/N |
|
Zeluf et al. (2018) [102] (Sweden) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 796 Trans feminine: 19% Trans masculine: 23% Gender nonbinary: 44% Transvestite: 14% Missing: 0.2% 15–94 years (not provided) |
Demographics TGD-related victimisation: 3-items (not specified); Stigma: SCS; Trans-related healthcare issues; 2-items; Change of legal gender: 1-item; Illicit drug use & risky alcohol consumption: 1-item each Life Satisfaction: Life Satisfaction Scale; Social Support: 1-item; Practical support: 1-item; Openness with trans identity: not specified |
Past year suicide ideation: Yes once; yes, several times; No Lifetime suicide attempts: Yes, between past 2 weeks & 1 year ago; yes, more than a year ago; No |
|
Zwickl et al. (2021) [103] (Australia) |
Cross-sectional |
n = 928 Trans male: 26% Trans female: 22% Gender non-binary: 14% Gender Queer: 4% Agender:2% Gender Fluid: 2% Gender Neutral: 1% Other - 3% 18–79 years (Median = 28 years) |
Demographics Access to gender affirming hormones; access to gender affirming surgery; Access to trans support groups (Y/N/Unsure); Perceived discrimination from employment, housing, healthcare, &/or government services: items about different aspects of these factors; Self-reported depression diagnosis: Y/N; Physical assault: Y/N |
Self-harm & suicide attempts: 1-item each Y/N/prefer not to say |
|
Papers are ordered alphabetically. | |
LEC-5 = Lifetime Events Checklist for DSM-5 | |
Abbreviations: | LOT-R = Life Orientation Test-Revised |
MTDG = Male to different gender | |
ACSS = Acquired Capability Suicide Scale | MDS = Modified Depression Scale |
ASAB = Assigned sex at birth | MSPSS = Multidimensional Scale of Perceived Social Support |
AUDIT = Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test | MTF = Male to Female |
BDI = Beck Discrimination Inventory | NHAI = Nungesser Homosexual Attitudes Inventory |
BIS = Body Investment Scale | NSSI = Nonsuicidal Self-Injury |
Brief-DAST = Brief Drug Abuse Screening Test | PANSI = Positive & Negative Suicide Ideation Inventory |
BRS = Brief Resilience Scale | PDS = Perceived Discrimination Scale |
BSI = Brief Symptom Inventory | PHQ-9 = Patient Health Questionnaire |
BSS = Beck Scale for Suicide Ideation | POC = Person of Colour |
CAPA = Child & Adolescent Psychological Abuse Measure | PPES = Painful & Provocative Events Scale |
CASSS = Child & Adolescent Social Support Scale | PSS-Fa = Perceived Social Support-Family |
CES-D = Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale | PSS-Fr = Perceived Social Support-Friends |
CBCL = Child Behavior Checklist | PTSD = Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder |
DASS-21 = Depression Anxiety Stress Scales | RFL = Reasons for Living Inventory |
DHEQ = Modified Daily Heterosexist Experiences Questionnaire | RHAI = Revised Homosexuality Attitude Inventory |
DERS-SF = Difficulties in Emotion Regulation Scale-Short Form | RHM = Reactions to Homosexuality Measure |
DSHI – Deliberate Self-Harm Inventory | RHS = Reactions to Homosexuality Scale |
EDS = Everyday Discrimination Scale | RSA = Resilience Scale for Adults |
FTDG – Female to different gender | RSE = Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale |
FTM = Female to male | SBQ-R = Suicide Behaviors Questionnaire-Revised |
GAD-7 = Generalised Anxiety Disorder Scale | SCL-90-R = Symptom Checklist 90-Revised |
GCS = Gender Conformity Scale | SCS = Stigma Consciousness Scale |
GICE = Gender Identity Change Efforts | SHBQ = Self-harm Behaviors Questionnaire |
GMSR = Gender Minority Stress & Resilience Measure | SHI = Self-Harm Inventory |
HADS = Hospital Anxiety & Depression Scale | SIDAS = Suicidal Ideation Attributes Scale |
HBDS = Hamburg Body Drawing Scale | SITBI = Self Injurous Thoughts & Behaviors Interview |
HRD = Harassment, rejection & discrimination | SIQ = Self-Injury Questionnaire |
HRDS = Heterosexist, Rejection, & Discrimination Scale | SIQ-TR = Self-Injury Questionnaire-Trauma Related |
HSCL-25 = Hopkins Symptoms Checklist-25 | SRI-25 = Suicide Resilience Inventory-25 |
IHS = Internalised Homonegativity Subscale | SS-A = Social Support Appraisals Scales |
IIP-32 = Inventory of Interpersonal Problems | STI = Sexually Transmitted Infections |
INQ = Interpersonal Needs Questionnaire | TAFE = Technical & Further Education |
INQ-R = Interpersonal Needs Questionnaire-Revised | TAIM = Transgender Adaption & Integration Measure |
ISAS = Non Suicidal Self-Injury and Inventory of Statements about Self-Injury | TCS = Transgender Congruence Scale |
IPTS = Interpersonal Psychological Theory of Suicide | TYC-GDS = Trans Youth CAN! Gender Distress Scale |
K-6 = Kessler Psychological Distress Scale-6 | TYC-GPS = Trans Youth CAN! Gender Positivity Scale |
K-10 – Kessler Psychological Distress Scale-10 | YRB = Youth Risk Behavior Survey |
YSR = Youth Self Report |