Table 6. The advantages and disadvantages of various anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction graft fixation methods.
Fixation method | Advantages | Disadvantages |
---|---|---|
Compression | • ↓ Graft-tunnel micromotion• ↓ Tunnel widening • ↓ Graft creep |
• Risk of screw-tunnel divergence • Graft damage • Cancellous fixation • Graft slippage |
Suspensory | • Minimally invasive • ↑ Tension between graft/bone interface • Cortical fixation • Similar biomechanics to compression |
• ↑ Graft-tunnel motion • “Windshield wiper phenomenon” • Tunnel widening |
Suture anchor | • Maintenance of tension | • Anchor pull-out |
Post/staple | • Useful in open physes• Useful in graft-tunnel mismatch • Stable, inflexible fixation |
• Hardware irritation • More invasive |
↓, decreased; ↑, increased.