Skip to main content
. 2024 Feb 24;40(3):btae109. doi: 10.1093/bioinformatics/btae109

Table 3.

Comparison of CryoTransformer with crYOLO and Topaz in terms of precision, recall, F1-score, and dice score of particle picking on the micrographs of six independent test proteins.

EMPIAR ID Type of protein Number of micrographs No. of particles in ground truth (CryoPPP dataset) Precision
Recall
F1 score
Dice score
CrYOLO Topaz CryoTransformer CrYOLO Topaz CryoTransformer CrYOLO Topaz CryoTransformer CrYOLO Topaz CryoTransformer
10017 β-galactosidase 84 49 391 0.695 0.57 0.745 0.024 0.998 0.587 0.046 0.726 0.657 0.041 0.694 0.623
10081 Transport 300 39 352 0.405 0.736 0.860 0.18 0.965 0.889 0.25 0.835 0.874 0.214 0.825 0.823
10093 Membrane 295 56 394 0.574 0.617 0.560 0.054 0.537 0.689 0.098 0.574 0.618 0.086 0.504 0.600
10345 Signaling 295 15 894 0.543 0.526 0.744 0.134 0.981 0.864 0.215 0.685 0.799 0.111 0.659 0.684
10532 Viral 300 87 933 0.715 0.672 0.813 0.201 0.976 0.665 0.313 0.796 0.732 0.239 0.757 0.614
11056 Transport 305 125 908 0.513 0.731 0.853 0.214 0.832 0.683 0.302 0.778 0.758 0.284 0.692 0.679
Average 0.574 0.642 0.7625 0.1345 0.8815 0.7295 0.204 0.732 0.740 0.163 0.689 0.671