Table 4. Summary of the different levels of analysis performed to assess the effect of short-term parasite culturing on var and core gene expression, their rational, method, results, and interpretation.
| Analysis level | Analysis | Rationale | Method | Results | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| var transcript | Per patient expression ranking | Relative quantification of var transcripts over consecutive generations of parasites originating from the same patient to reveal var gene switching events | Combine assembled var transcripts for each patient into a reference and quantify expression, validated with DBLα-tag analysis | 46% of the patient samples had a change in the dominant or top 3 highest expressed var gene | Modest changes in most samples, but unpredictable var gene switching during culture in some samples |
| Per patient var expression homogeneity (VEH) | Determine the overall diversity of var gene expression (number of different variants expressed and their abundance) to assess impact of culturing on the overall var gene expression pattern | Comparison of diversity curves based on per patient quantification of the var transcriptome | 39% of ex vivo samples diversity curves distinct from in vitro samples | Some patient samples underwent a much greater var transcriptional change compared to others | |
| Conserved var variants | Assessing and comparing the expression levels of strain-transcendent var gene variants (var1, var2csa, var3) between samples | Reference of all assembled transcripts for each conserved var gene and quantify expression | var2csa expression increases in second in vitro generation | Parasites converge to var2csa during short-term in vitro culture | |
| var-encoded PfEMP1 domains | Differential expression of PfEMP1 domains | Identification, quantification, and comparison of expression levels of different var gene-encoded PfEMP1 domains associated with different disease manifestations | Pool all assembled var transcripts into a reference and quantify expression of each domain | 46% of the ex vivo samples cluster away from their in vitro samples in PCA plots, distinct clustering by in vitro generation was not observed; CIDRα2.5 significantly differentially expressed between ex vivo and generation 1 | Transition to culture results in modest modulation of particular var domains |
| var group | Expression of NTS (NTSA vs NTSB) and DBLα (DBLα1 vs DBLα0+DBLα2) | Quantification and comparison of expression levels of different var gene groups (group A vs. groups B and C) | Create a reference of all assembled DBLα and NTS domains for each patient and quantify expression. Validated with DBLα-tag analysis |
No significant changes | No preferential up- or downregulation of certain var groups during transition to culture |
| Global var expression | LARSFADIG coverage | Assessing the overall var gene expression level (excluding var2csa) | Assemble the LARSFADIG motif and map non-core reads to quantify coverage | Trend for decrease in global var expression during culture, but no significant changes | Subtle reduction in global var gene expression may reflect increase in parasite age during culture |
| Core genes | Differential gene expression (DGE) | Assessing the impact of cultivation on the parasite core gene transcriptome | Differential expression analysis of core genes (P. falciparum 3D7 used as reference) | 19% of the core transcriptome significantly differentially expressed between paired ex vivo and generation 1 in vitro samples; distinct clustering by parasite generation observed; upregulation of invasion and replication-related genes in vitro | Parasites core gene expression changes substantially upon entering culture |