Skip to main content
. 2024 Mar 11;10(6):e27562. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e27562

Table 8.

Differences in myopia control effects of different OK lenses (different brands or designs).

Study Difference in the design of OK lenses Study time Country or area Number of eyes Criteria Efficacy of myopia control
Mj Zhu, Hy Feng and Xm Qu [6] Different brand (hidden) One year China Brand 1: 102
Brand 2: 50
Brand 3: 102
Change in AL Brand 1 = Brand 2
Brand 2 = Brand 3
Brand 3>Brand 1
Pauline Kang and Helen Swarbrick [7] BE, Australia
Paragon CRT, USA
Contex, USA
Two weeks Australia BE: 38
CRT: 19
Contex: 19
Relative peripheral refraction changes Differed minimally among the three OK lens
Ruru Chen, Colm McAlinden et al. [8] Essence, USA
Euclid, USA
Lucid, Korea
Moldway, China
Two years China Essence: 51x2
Euclid: 51x2
Lucid: 46x2
Moldway: 53x2
Change in AL Essence > Moldway
Other intergroups: Equal
Nakamura Y, Kinoshita S. et al. [9] Menicon, Japan
Alpha, Japan
Emerald, America
Two years Japan Menicon: 24x2
Alpha: 28x2
Emerald: 27x2
Change in AL and refractive error Menicon = Alpha = Emerald
Lu W, Jin W. et al. [10] CRT vs. VST (Euclid, America
Alpha, Japan
Hiline, China)
1.5 years China CRT: 263
Euclid: 277
Alpha: 236
Hiline: 225
Change in AL Euclid, Alpha, Hiline > CRT
Euclid = Alpha
Alpha = Hiline
Euclid > Hiline
Pauné J, Queirós A. et al. [12] Different back optical zone diameters One year Spain Larger diameter (>5 mm): 36
Smaller diameter (≤5 mm): 35
Change in AL Smaller diameter > Larger diameter
Guo B. Cho P. et al. [13] Different back optic zone diameters One year China 6 mm: 34
5 mm: 36
Change in AL Lens with 5 mm diameter > Lens with 6 mm diameter
Loertscher M, Phillips JR. et al. [14] New multifocal orthokeratology vs. Conventional orthokeratology 1.5 years New Zealand 30 (Paired-eye study) Change in AL New multifocal > Conventional
Wan K, Cho P. et al. [15] Different compression factors (0.75 D vs. 1.75 D) Two years China 0.75 D: 29
1.75 D: 35
Change in AL Increased compression factors (1.75 D) > Conventional compression factors (0.75 D)