Box 2.
Summary of published trials to prevent/delay incident clinical RA in at-risk populations*
| Study | Inclusion criteria | Study design and intervention | Primary outcome | Major findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bos et al 2010 | RF and/or ACPA positive shared epitope positive; arthralgia | RCT; dexamethasone 100 mg IM x 2 doses vs placebo | Incident clinical IA | 17/83 (21%) developed IA after a median follow-up of 26 months; no difference between arms (dexamethasone 21% vs placebo 20%); Dexamethasone use associated with decreased autoantibody levels |
| Gerlag et al 2019 (PRAIRI) | RF and ACPA positive; CRP >0.6 mg/L; arthralgia | RCT; rituximab 1000 mg x 1 dose (and steroid) vs placebo | Incident clinical IA | 30/81 (37%) developed IA after a mean follow-up of 29 months; no significant difference in overall rates of IA between arms (rituximab 14/41 (34%), placebo 14/40 (40%)); rituximab associated with delay of onset of IA |
| van Boheemen et al 2021 (StapRA) | RF and ACPA positive or ACPA >3x ULN; arthralgia | RCT; atorvastatin 40 mg/day x 3 years vs placebo | Incident clinical IA | 15/62 (24%) developed IA after a median follow-up of 14 months; no significant difference between arms (atorvastatin 9/31 (29%) vs placebo 6/31 (19%) |
| Krijbolder et al 2022 (TREAT EARLIER) | Arthralgia and MRI evidence of joint inflammation but without clinical swollen joint; RF/ACPA not required for inclusion although 33% of participants were RF and/or ACPA positive | RCT; methylprednisolone 120 mg x 1 dose and methotrexate up to 25 mg/week x 1 year vs placebo; 1-year post-drug follow-up | RA by 2010 criteria present at 2 time points 2 weeks apart | 44/236 (~19%) developed RA over the 2 years of the trial; no significant differences between arms (methotrexate 23/119 (19%), placebo 21/117 (18%); decreased measures of physical function, pain and MRI inflammation in MTX treated group. The highest rate of RA development was within ACPA+ individuals (27/54=50%), although there was no significant difference in rates between arms at 2 years. |
| Hahn et al 2022 (VITAL) | Individuals without cancer or cardiovascular disease | RCT; omega-3 fatty acid (1000 mg/day) and/or vitamin D (2000 IU/day) vs placebo x 5 years | Incident autoimmune disease (including RA) by chart review | Vitamin D supplementation for five years, with or without omega-3 fatty acids, reduced aggregate incidence of autoimmune disease, including RA, by ~22%. |
| Rech et al 2024 (ARIAA) | ACPA positive and MRI evidence of joint inflammation | RCT; abatacept 125 mg SQ weekly x 6 months vs placebo; 12-month post-drug follow-up | MRI inflammatory parameter improvement; clinical RA | At 18 months there was significant MRI improvement in abatacept arm compared to placebo (28/49 (57%) vs 14/49 (29%)). At 18 months there was also significantly less progression to clinical RA in abatacept arm compared to placebo (17/49 (35%) vs 28/49 (57%)). |
| Deane et al 2022 (StopRA)** | ACPA >=2x ULN | RCT; hydroxychloroquine 200–400 mg/day x 1 year versus placebo; 2 years post-drug follow-up | RA by 2010 criteria | In preliminary analyses, 43/144 (~30%) developed RA over the 3 years of the study; no significant differences between arms (24/71 (34%), placebo 26/73 (36%); trial halted and final analyses pending |
| Cope et al 2024 (APIPPRA) | ACPA+RF positive or ACPA >=3x normal and arthralgia | RCT; abatacept 125 mg weekly injection x 1 year versus placebo; 1-year post-drug follow-up | RA by 2010 criteria | At 2 years, 65/213 (~31%) of participants developed RA by 2010 criteria; 25% in abatacept arm and 37% in placebo arm. This resulted in differences in mean arthritis-free survival time between arms of ~99 days (p=0.002). In exploratory analyses, the highest risk for progression was individuals with multiple positive autoantibodies; this group also had the best response to abatacept. |
While the inclusion criteria varied across studies, across the studies the participants could not have clinical RA at baseline defined as the presence on physical examination of a swollen joint consistent with synovitis.
The results from StopRAhave only been presented in abstract form.
Abbreviations: RA=rheumatoid arthritis; ACPA=antibodies to citrullinated protein antigens; RF=rheumatoid factor; RCT=randomized controlled trial; ULN=upper limit of normal; SQ=subcutaneous; MRI magnetic resonance imaging; MTX=methotrexate; IM=intramuscular; IA=inflammatory arthritis; IU=international units