Table 2.
Nomograms on prediction of pathologic stage in men treated with radical prostatectomy for clinically localized prostate cancer
Study | Prediction model | Outcome measure | No of Patients | Variables | Discrimination |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Partin et al59 | Probability table | Pathologic stage | 703/4133 | Biopsy GS, CS, PSA | Internal: 72% External: 84% |
Epstein et al7 | Risk group | Clinically indolent cancer defined as pathologically organ confined, tumor volume ≤0.2 cc, GS < 7 | 157 | Biopsy GS, millimeter core with cancer, PSAD, no adverse pathologic findings on needle biopsy | NA |
Kattan et al8 | Probability nomogram development | Clinically indolent cancer defined as pathologically organ confined, tumor volume ≤0.5 cc, no GG 4 or 5 | 409 | PSA, primary and secondary biopsy GS, volume, millimeter core with cancer, millimeter core without cancer | 64% |
Chun et al60 | Probability nomogram development | Gleason upgrading between biopsy and RP | 2982 | PSA, CS, primary and secondary Biopsy GS |
80% |
Chun et al61 | Probability nomogram development | Significant Gleason upgrading between biopsy and RP | 4789 | PSA, CS, biopsy GS | 76% |
Ackerman et al62 | Probability formula | Surgical margin positivity | 107 | Number positive sextant cores, PSAD | 70% |
Bostwick et al63 | Probability graph | Capsular penetration | 314 | Biopsy GS, Percent cancer in biopsy cores, PSA | 78% |
Gamito et al64 | Neural network | Capsular penetration | 4133 | Age, race, PSA, PSAV, GS, CS | 30–76% |
Gilliland et al65 | Probability graph | ECE | 3826 | Age, biopsy GS, PSA | 63% |
Steuber et al39 | Probability nomogram development | Side-specific ECE | 1118 | PSA, CS, biopsy GS, percent Positive cores, percent of cancer in positive cores | 84% |
Baccala et al66 | Probability nomogram development | SV invasion | 6740 | Age, PSA, Biopsy GS, CS | 80% |
Gallina et al67 | Probability nomogram development | SV invasion | 896 | PSA, CS, biopsy GS, percent positive biopsy cores | 79% |
Bluestein et al68 | Probability graph | LN invasion assessed with limited pelvic lymphadenectomy | 816 | Biopsy GS, CS, PSA | 82% |
Batuello et al69 | Neural network | LN invasion assessed with limited pelvic lymphadenectomy | 6454 | Biopsy GS, CS, PSA | 77–81% |
Briganti et al70 | Probability nomogram development | LN assessed with extended pelvic lymphadenectomy (≥10 nodes) | 602 | PSA, CS, biopsy GS | 76% |
Kim et al50 | Probability nomogram development | LN invasion assessed with extended pelvic lymphadenectomy | 541 | PSA, CS, GS | Internal: 88.3% External: NA |
GS, Gleason sum; CS, clinical stage; PSA, prostate specific antigen; PSAD, prostate specific antigen density; GG, Gleason grade; RP, radical prostatectomy; PSAV, prostate specific antigen velocity; ECE, extracapsular extension; SV, seminal vesicle; LN, lymph node; NA, not available.