TABLE 2.
Comparison of key experimental steps and technical components of the OECD TG442E GARDskin method and the GARDskin Medical Device protocols.
| Experimental step/technical component | TG 442E GARDskin | GARDskin medical device |
|---|---|---|
| Cellular test system | SenzaCell cell line (ATCC Depository PTA-123875) | SenzaCell cell line (ATCC Depository PTA-123875) |
| Test itema | Pure monoconstituent chemical | Test material extract |
| Vehicles/extraction vehicles a | DMSO, dH2O (Final in-well concentration 0.1%) | Olive oil, Sesame oil, saline (Final in-well concentration 10%) |
| Default top concentration for cytotoxicity screening1 | 500 μM (pure test item concentration) | 10% (test material extract concentration) |
| GARDskin input concentration | Rv90-concentration or default top concentration. Identical in all replicate samples | Rv90-concentration or default top concentration. Allowed to vary across replicate samples |
| Positive control | PPD, administered in accepted vehicle | PPD, administered in accepted vehicle |
| Negative control | Blank vehicle at in-well concentration | Blank vehicle at in-well concentration |
| Endpoint measurement | Quantified gene expression of the GARDskin GPS | Quantified gene expression of the GARDskin GPS |
| Analysis pipeline | Default GARDskin analysis pipeline b | Default GARDskin analysis pipeline b |
| Prediction model1 | Mean DV ≥ 0: sensitizer | Mean DV in any one vehicle ≥0: sensitizer |
Notable difference.
For details, cf OECD, 2022a.