Skip to main content
. 2024 Mar 11;16(3):429. doi: 10.3390/v16030429

Table 1.

Sociodemographic and clinical characteristics of the included studies.

Characteristics N = 112 %
Age range
  • 2 years

35 31.3
  • <5 years

22 19.6
  • <10 years

4 3.6
  • <15 years

20 17.9
  • <18 years

27 24.1
  • Not reported

4 3.6
Male range (%) 39.1–73.8%
Period of inclusion of participants; range January 2015–December 2022
Year of publication; range 2017–2023
Study design
  • Cross-sectional

75 67
  • Longitudinal

37 33
Sampling method
  • Consecutive

110 98.2
  • Random

2 1.8
Timing of data collection
  • Ambispective

4 3.6
  • Prospective

58 51.8
  • Retrospective

50 44.6
Study bias
  • Low risk

71 63.4
  • Moderate risk

41 36.6
WHO region
  • African

7 6.3
  • Americas

13 11.6
  • Eastern Mediterranean

3 2.7
  • European

47 42
  • South–East Asia

8 7.1
  • Western Pacific

34 30.4
Type of assay
  • Immune assays ¥

22 19.6
  • Molecular assays ¥¥

85 75.9
  • Mixed assays ¥¥¥

5 4.5
Diagnostic technique $
  • Antigen

6 5.4
  • Direct immunofluorescence

16 14.3
  • Mixed ¥¥¥

5 4.5
  • Multiplex PCR

14 12.5
  • Multiplex RT–PCR

18 16.1
  • PCR

16 14.3
  • qPCR

2 1.8
  • RT–PCR

31 27.7
  • RT–qPCR

4 3.6
Sample type
  • Mixed *

7 6.3
  • Nasal secretions

9 8
  • Nasopharyngeal secretions

62 55.4
  • Nasopharyngeal secretions or BLF

11 9.8
  • Not reported

8 7.1
  • Oropharyngeal swab

7 6.3
  • Sputum

3 2.7
  • Throat swab

5 4.5

¥ Immune assays: antigen testing or direct immunofluorescence. ¥¥ Molecular assays: multiplex PCR, multiplex RT–PCR, PCR, qPCR, RT–PCR, or RT–qPCR. ¥¥¥ Mixed assays: antigen testing/RT–PCR, direct immunofluorescence/RT–qPCR/antigen testing, direct immunofluorescence/RT–PCR, or indirect immunofluorescence/PCR. $ The indicated diagnostic technique is according to the authors’ description. * Mixed specimens: nasopharyngeal secretions and nasal secretions or nasal and throat secretions. Abbreviations: WHO, World Health Organization; BLF, bronchoalveolar lavage fluid.