Table 2.
Various methods used for obtaining nanopropolis with the size’s result.
| Application | Type of bionanomaterial | Synthesis methods | Composition | Size, nm | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Anti-diabetes | Nano-spheres powder of extract ethanol propolis encapsulated chitosan-polyacrilic nanoparticles | Chitosan-poly acrylic acid (CS-PAA) polymer was synthesized by converting chitin to chitosan through a deacetylation process, followed by mixing the chitosan solution with polyacrylic acid and stirring overnight. Then, ethanolic extract of propolis (EEP) was conjugated with the CS-PAA polymer using a a home-made rod mill, then sonicated, and centrifuged | Chitosan, ethanol extract of propolis, 0.66 mM potassium persulphate (KPS), acrylic acid, 0.1 N hydrochloric acid (HCl) | 24-32 | [99] |
| Nanopropolis lyophilized powder | Extract ethanol propolis was lyophilized and dried | Ethanol extract of propolis, ethanol | <100 | [87] | |
| Nanopropolis emulsion | Spontaneous emulsification method. Dissolving propolis extract into an organic phase containing soy lecithin ad mix with aqueous phase containing poloxamer |
0.4 % of poloxamer, 2.5 mg/mL of soy lecithin, acetone and ethanol with ratiof 60:40 | 122.1 | [100] | |
| Hepatoprotective | Nanopropolis polymeric micelles solution | Micellar formulation method. Adding propolis extract to triblock copolymer solution and evaporated to remove ethanol | 0.06734 g ml-1 PEO26PPO40PEO26 triblock copolymer, 0.055 g ml-1 of propolis extract, ethanol:water (70:30) | 21 | [101] |
| Propolis liposome | All materials were mixed with ethanol and water while heated in 80 °C. Then, the solution was homogenized in ultra-turrax homogenizer at 11000 rpm. Then, the liposome dispersion was obtained. | 160 mg of phospholipids (PL-90H), 80 mg of cholesterol, 100 mg stearic acid, 30 mg of propolis extract, and ethanol | 216 to 437 | [102] | |
| Anti-cancer | Chitosan-coated nano-propolis | Green sonication method by adding chitosan into acetic acid solution then sonicated. Tween 80 was added and mixed with propolis ethanol solution. Subsequently, the solution was sonicated and stored in cold. | 3.5 g chitosan, 2 vol.% acetic acid, 1 g of tween 80, propolis (85 %), 120 mL ethanol | <200 | [96] |
| Propolis nanosuspension | Nanoprecipitation method by dissolving a half of total propolis to DMSO 5 % and the rest in ethanol, then it was sonicated. Propolis solutions added to distilled water containing lecithin, while in stirring. Nanosuspension obtained after ethanol evaporated | 5 % dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO), 2 ml lecithin, ethanol, distilled water, and propolis extract | 185.27 ± 26.44 | [103] | |
| Niosome vesicle of propolis | Ether injection method in synthesizing niosomes. Diethyl ether solution was prepared and dissolving cholesterol and tween 80, then propolis extract in PBS solution added to the mixture. Niosome was obtained by centrifugation and lyophilized in extreme cold temperature | Cholesterol, tween 80, diethylether, PBS pH 7.4 and propolis extract | 151 ± 2.84 | [104] | |
| Nanoparticle propolis | Propolis extract dissolved in ethanol and shaking in water bath. Then it was filtered and diluted in distilled water. Propolis water solution sonicated and filtered using a 220nm PTFE filter | Ethanol, water and propolis powder extract | 43.82 to 91.28 | [86] | |
| Propolis-loaded nanostructured lipid carrier | High-shear homogenization. A lipid phase mixed with propolis ethanol solution and heated in water bath above melting point of lipid. Aqueous phase was prepared containing emulsifier. Lipid and aqueous phase mixed with Ultra Turrax homogenizer at the same temperature |
Liquid lipid, Poloxamer 188, Poloxamer 407, ethanol, propolis extract | 255.8 to 342.5 | [105] | |
| Zinc Oxide-Propolis Nanocomposite | Propolis nanoparticle prepared by ball mill method and Zinc oxide nanoparticle obtained by coprecipitated using zinc nitrate and propolis aqueous extract. Then, ZnO-Propolis Nanocomposite synthesize by green synthesis approach by mixing both propolis and ZnO nanoparticle and centrifuged in 4 times | zinc nitrate, milli-Q water, propolis | 9.70 | [106] | |
| Propolis-loaded nano-in-microparticles | Propolis extract solid dispersion loaded to polymeric materials such as poly(lactic-co-glycolic acid) (PLGA) and poly(ethylene glycol)-block-poly (propylene glycol)-block-poly(ethylene glycol). PE loaded polymer were dispersed in chitosan solution formed NIM (nano-in-microparticles) | polyvinyl alcohol, poly(ethylene glycol)-block-poly (propylene glycol)-block-poly(ethylene glycol), PLGA, polyethylene glycol, gelucire, Sodium dodecyl sulfate | 104 to 1921 | [107] | |
| Propolis solid lipid nanoparticles | Hot homogenization method and ultrasonication. Propolis nano-emulsion placed in cold water to obtain solid lipid nanoparticles | Tween20, Tween80, solid lipid, ethanolic extract of propolis. | 57.55 ± 15 | [108] | |
| Propolis nanocapsule | Ultrasound and high-speed homogenizer method. First, propolis extract in aqueous solution prepared and adding water gradually in stirring. High speed homogenizer used to obtain nanoemulsion. sodium alginate added to nanoemulsion then ultrasonicated to obtain encapsulation emulsion | supercritical fluid carbon dioxide extract of propolis, deionized water, sodium alginate | 18.87to 39.12 | [109] | |
| Cardiovascular disease | Liposomal propolis | Liposome obtained by modification on dried thin lipid film technique. Then, propolis extract in ethanol mixed with liposome and vortexed. Propolis liposome obtained by evaporating ethanol solvent. | 0.25gram L-α phosphatidylcholine, 0.25gram cholesterol. 15 ml chloroform, phosphate buffer, ethanol, propolis extract. | 93.5 ± 0.87 | [110] |
| Propolis loaded triblock copolymer nano-vesicles | Thin film hydration method | Polylactide-block-poly (ethylene glycol)-block-polylactide (PLA-PEG-PLA), ethanol, propolis extract | 23-53 | [111] | |
| Anti-virus | Propolis-loaded chitosan/PLGA | oil-in-water (o/w) single emulsion solvent evaporation method | PLGA, PVA, chitosan, Dichloromethane, ethanolic extract of propolis | 450 | [112] |
| Propolis-loaded PLGA nanoparticle | oil-in-water (o/w) single emulsion solvent evaporation method | PLGA, PVA, Dichloromethane, ethanolic extract of propolis | 229.5 to 424.7 | [113] | |
| Propolis-chitosan nanoparticle | Chitosan nanoparticle prepared by ionic gelation method using tripolyphosphate solution and acetic acid. Then, chitosan was added to ethanolic propolis extract with tween 20 using peristaltic pump. while stirring | 0.1% (w/v) chitosan, tripolyphosphate, 1% glacial acetic acid, ethanolic propolis extract, Tween 20 | 50 to 200 | [97] | |
| Propolis nanofiber | Electrospinning method and fabrication of nanowebs | 6 wt% PVA, propolis glycerin extract, propolis extracts containing ethyl alcohol | >5000 | [92] | |
| Antibiotics, antibacteria | Chitosan propolis nanoparticle | Ionotropic gelation method with Tripolyphosphate (TPP). 0.2% Chitosan solution was prepared in 1% acetic acid at ph 5.0. Then, ethanol extract of propolis added while stirring. TPP solution prepared in distilled water and adjusted to ph5.5. chitosan-propolis solution added into TPP under stirring condition | 0.2% w/v of chitosan, 0.15% w/v sodium TPP, 1% v/v acetic acid, ethanol extract of propolis | 107.74 ± 0.53 | [114] |
| Nanopropolis | Ball mill media method using ball or rods | Propolis extract and methanol | 122 to 409 | [115] | |
| Propolis nanoemulsion | Chitosan solution prepared in 1 % lactic acid then mixed with 0.4 % TPP solution. Suspension obtained by stirring in overnight. 35 % of glycerol-sorbitol solution (2:1) added to suspension. Propolis extract was added to form nanoemulsion | Chitosan, 1 % lactic acid, 0.4 % TPP solution, 35 % of glycerol-sorbitol solution (2:1), propolis extract | 71.16 to 112.34 | [116] | |
| Propolis- nanostructured lipid carrier | Emulsion-evaporation-solidification method. Propolis extract dissolved in lipid phase with lecithin in ethanol and heated. Tween 80 in water as aqueous phase mixed with lipid phase in dropwise and then sonicated | Glycerol monostearate, capric acid, lecithin, ethanol, tween-80, propolis extract | 41.57 to 44.28 | [117] | |
| Propolis micellar nanocomposite | A combination of polymeric nanocomposite mixed with propolis ethyl acetate extract. Then, acetone used for solubilize the micellar nanocomposites loaded propolis | poly-ε-caprolactone (PCL), Pluronic F108 copolymer, acetone propolis ethyl acetate extract | >70 | [118] | |
| PVA-loaded nanopropolis | PVA solution was prepared and mix with propolis extract while shaking at 80 °C for 1 h. The solution was continued homogenized in 24 hour using magnetic stirrer. The sample weas filtered and put into electrospray to obtain PVA-nanopropolis | 6 % of PVA, Propolis extract | 106.37 to 258.51 | [119] | |
| Anti-inflammation | Propolis nanoparticles | Emulsion diffusion method. Propolis in 90 % ethyl alcohol was added drop wise into polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) in aqueous solution under stirring. Then propolis nanoparticle obtained by centrifugation | 1 % of polyvinyl alcohol (PVA), ethyl alcohol, propolis, distilled water | 5 to 10 | [98] |
| Propolis supercritical extract encapsulated in gamma- cyclodextrin | Propolis extract mixed with cyclodextrin in aqueous solution and homogenized. Then, suspension was dispersed in water and spray-dried | Green propolis supercritical extract, gamma cyclodextrin, water | <6000 | [120] | |
| Oral and dental disease | Colloidal nanopropolis | Propolis extract was filtered and added to distilled water. The suspension was sonicated to obtain colloidal nanopropolis. pH of nanopropolis adjusted to 7 with natrium hydroxide. The result was then powdered using freeze-drying process | Propolis, ethanol, natrium hydroxide | 70 to 120 | [121] |
| Niosomal propolis extract | Reversed phase evaporation method | Span60, cholesterol, chloroform, ethanol, water, propolis extract, | 237 to 333 | [122] | |
| Wound healing | Nanofiber propolis-silk fibroin gelatin | Silk fibroin was prepared first from silk cocoons using degumming and lyophilization method. Gelatin mixed with silk fibroin and propolis extract was added. Then, solution was processed into nanofiber using electrospinning method. | silk cocoons, lithium bromide, water, formic acid, gelatin, | 100 to 600 | [123] |
| Nanofiber propolis gel patches | Electrospinning method. 3 % of gelatin added to PVA solution and mixed with tween 80 and propolis. Then the solution introduced to electrospinning | PVA, Tween 80 propolis, gelatin | 293 to 401 | [93] | |
| Nanofiber propolis | Electrospinning method. Propolis was mixed with polymeric solution and 1,1,1,3,3,3-hexafluoro-2-propanol was used as solvent. Then, the mixture introduced to electrospinning | poly(lactide-co-glycolide), propolis, | n/a | [95] | |
| Propolis loaded cellulose nanofiber /polyvinyl alcohol hydrogel | Freeze-thawing and freeze-drying method | PVA. Cellulose nanofiber, propolis extract, distilled water, | <20000 | [124] |