Table 3.
Wlicoxon test results of each variant algorithm.
| F | Index | IIHHO | IIHHO-I | IIHHO-II | IIHHO-III | IIHHO-IV | IIHHO-V | IIHHO-VI |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| F1 | Context | 3.0199E−11(+) | 4.0772E−11(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) |
| F2 | Context | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.3384E−11(+) | 2.3715E−10(−) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.3383E−11(+) | 5.4620E−06(−) |
| F3 | Context | 3.3520E−08(+) | 2.8790E−06(+) | 8.9934E−11(−) | 1.1023E−08(−) | 6.5277E−08(+) | 2.6015E−08(+) | 4.9752E−11(−) |
| F4 | Context | 4.9752E−11(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.0199E−11(−) | 8.9934E−11(−) | 2.7726E−05(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.0199E−11(−) |
| F5 | Context | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) |
| F6 | Context | 1.1747E−04(+) | 7.2446E−02(=) | 4.3584E−02(−) | 8.6844E−03(+) | 7.1988E−05(+) | 1.4532E−01(=) | 5.0842E−03(−) |
| F7 | Context | 1.3703E−03(+) | 7.6588E−05(+) | 6.7350E−01(=) | 1.2235E−01(=) | 1.1228E−02(+) | 4.0595E−02(+) | 6.5486E−04(−) |
| F8 | Context | 4.1191E−01(=) | 3.1830E−01(=) | 5.7929E−01(=) | 7.7311E−01(=) | 1.8577E−01(=) | 5.8945E−01(=) | 9.3519E−01(=) |
| F9 | Context | 6.1452E−02(=) | 3.4029E−01(=) | 3.9881E−04(−) | 7.0617E−01(=) | 6.1001E−01(=) | 8.3146E−03(−) | 8.6634E−05(−) |
| F10 | Context | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 9.9186E−11(−) | 1.1567E−07(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 4.0772E−11(−) |
| F11 | Context | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 1.6062E−06(−) | 1.9963E−05(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.6897E−11(+) | 9.8329E−08(−) |
| F12 | Context | 1.5846E−04(+) | 1.8090E−01(=) | 1.9527E−03(+) | 4.2175E−04(+) | 2.0058E−04(+) | 1.0763E−02(+) | 1.1058E−04(+) |
| F13 | Context | 5.8945E−01(=) | 4.4272E−03(−) | 3.8481E−03(−) | 2.3985E−01(=) | 8.6844E−03(−) | 2.8913E−03(−) | 2.6509E−03(−) |
| F14 | Context | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.8249E−09(+) | 1.3345E−01(=) | 1.7666E−03(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 7.7725E−09(+) | 3.2651E−02(+) |
| F15 | Context | 3.8249E−09(+) | 2.1327E−05(+) | 5.828E−03(+) | 1.8575E−03(+) | 2.1947E−08(+) | 1.3367E−05(+) | 2.3800E−03(+) |
| F16 | Context | 2.7829E−07(+) | 3.6322E−01(=) | 3.1821E−04(+) | 7.5059E−01(=) | 1.3111E−08(+) | 2.4994E−03(+) | 1.5638E−02(+) |
| F17 | Context | 3.0199E−11(+) | 7.7725E−09(+) | 1.4643E−10(+) | 5.5611E−03(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.1830E−03(+) | 2.6099E−10(+) |
| F18 | Context | 3.0939E−06(+) | 8.1200E−04(+) | 3.8349E−06(+) | 6.7869E−02(=) | 2.7829E−07(+) | 7.2883E−03(−) | 1.4067E−04(+) |
| F19 | Context | 3.0199E−11(+) | 4.0772E−11(+) | 3.4971E−09(−) | 7.9585E−01(=) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 2.0338E−09(+) | 4.1997E−10(−) |
| F20 | Context | 4.4074E−03(−) | 7.6164E−01(=) | 3.2495E−01(=) | 8.9983E−01(=) | 2.8964E−01(=) | 9.1156E−01(=) | 5.1027E−01(=) |
| F21 | Context | 8.6844E−03(−) | 1.8368E−02(−) | 5.5546E−02(=) | 8.5641E−04(+) | 3.5638E−04(+) | 8.6844E−03(−) | 1.9527E−03(+) |
| F22 | Context | 3.0199E−11(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 1.1738E−03(−) | 4.4592E−04(+) | 3.0199E−11(+) | 2.1544E−10(+) | 7.0127E−02(=) |
| F23 | Context | 2.6243E−03(+) | 1.0407E−04(+) | 5.8945E−01(=) | 4.8413E−02(+) | 2.2539E−04(+) | 4.0595E−02(+) | 6.3088E−01(=) |
| F24 | Context | 1.5367E−01(=) | 3.3874E−02(−) | 2.0023E−06(−) | 6.7867E−02(=) | 6.3532E−02(=) | 1.1228E−02(−) | 2.8314E−08(−) |
| F25 | Context | 9.3519E−01(=) | 9.0490E−02(=) | 1.5969E−03(−) | 1.9073E−01(=) | 6.3532E−02(=) | 3.7782E−02(=) | 2.6806E−04(=) |
| F26 | Context | 6.3533E−02(=) | 5.5923E−01(=) | 2.7726E−05(−) | 7.2884E−03(−) | 2.0681E−02(−) | 2.2360E−02(−) | 3.2555E−07(−) |
| F27 | Context | 1.1882E−01(=) | 6.4142E−01(=) | 3.1573E−05(−) | 2.7071E−01(=) | 6.6689E−03(−) | 9.2113E−05(−) | 3.3679E−04(−) |
| F28 | Context | 5.8945E−01(=) | 9.5873E−01(=) | 3.4783E−01(=) | 4.4642E−01(=) | 8.5338E−01(=) | 2.9727E−01(=) | 7.2446E−02(=) |
| + / = /- | 18/8/2 | 15/10/3 | 7/7/14 | 13/12/3 | 19/6/3 | 16/5/7 | 9/6/13 | |