Table 1.
Proposed Analytic Permutations: 360 Total Modeling Combinations for MID task
First-level Pipeline Decisions | Options |
---|---|
A. Smoothing (FWHM) | |
1. 1.5x voxel | ON / OFF |
2. 2x voxel | ON / OFF |
3. 2.5x voxel | ON / OFF |
4. 3x voxel | ON / OFF |
5. 3.5x voxel | ON / OFF |
B. Motion Correction | |
1. None | ON / OFF |
2. Regress: Translation/Rotation (x,y,z) + Derivative (x,y,z) | ON / OFF |
3. Regress: Regress: Translation/Rotation (x,y,z) + Derivative (x,y,z) + First 8 aCompCor Components | ON / OFF |
4. Regress: Translation/Rotation (x,y,z) + Derivative (x,y,z) + First 8 aCompCor Components + Censor High Motion Volumes (FD ≥ .9) | ON / OFF |
#5. Regress: Translation/Rotation (x,y,z) + Derivative (x,y,z) + First 8 aCompCor Components, Exclude mean FD ≥ .9 | ON / OFF |
#6. Regress: Translation/Rotation (x,y,z) + Derivative (x,y,z) + First 8 aCompCor Components + Censor High Motion Volumes, Exclude mean FD ≥ .9 | ON / OFF |
C. Task Modeling | |
1. MID: Cue Onset, Cue Duration only | ON / OFF |
2. MID: Cue Onset, Cue + Fixation Duration | ON / OFF |
3. MID: Fixation onset, Fixation Duration | ON / OFF |
D. Task Contrasts | |
1. MID: Big Win > Neutral | ON / OFF |
2. MID: Big Win > Implicit | ON / OFF |
3. MID: Small Win > Neutral | ON / OFF |
4. MID: Small Win > Implicit | ON / OFF |
Blue text: Model hypothesized to produce the highest test-retest reliability; aCompCor: Anatomical Component Based Noise Correction; MID: Monetary Incentive Delay task; FD: Framewise displacement.
Due to the lack of low motion subjects (zero mean FD <.90 in 2/3 samples), this decision was not included in the Stage 2 analyses, resulting in 240 analytic models.