Table 3.
Potential clinicopathological scenarios where biopsy-based transcriptomics might help with diagnosis
| Banff Classification Category | Banff Classification sub-category | Histological challenge | How would biopsy-based transcriptomics help? | References |
| Normal biopsy or nonspecific changes | Banff lesion scores below threshold for rejection (TCMR or AMR) | Is there molecular TCMR? Is there molecular AMR? How severe is the injury-repair response? |
[15,24▪▪,26▪▪] | |
| DSA-positive, negative histology | Is there molecular AMR? | [22▪▪,24▪▪,53] | ||
| Acute tubular injury | How severe is the injury-repair response? | [45▪] | ||
| Antibody-mediated rejection | Active AMR | Probable AMR (DSA+ with g1, ptc1, v or TMA) | Is there molecular AMR? | [24▪▪] |
| MVI+ DSA- C4d- | Is there molecular AMR? Can molecular findings distinguish causes of MVI (e.g. HLA antibody, non-HLA antibody, missing self, etc)? |
[17,24▪▪,50] | ||
| Chronic/chronic active AMR | Degree of injury-repair response? Degree of chronicity? |
[45▪,61] | ||
| C4d staining without evidence of rejection | Is there molecular AMR? | [13] | ||
| Borderline for TCMR | Is there molecular TCMR? Is there molecular AMR? |
[15,31,62] | ||
| TCMR | TCMR grade II and III | Presence of endarteritis | Is there molecular TCMR? Is there molecular AMR? |
[52] |
| Chronic-active TCMR | i-IFTA lesion | Is there molecular TCMR? Is there molecular AMR? How severe is the injury-repair response? |
[54] | |
| Mixed AMR and TCMR | Is there molecular TCMR? Is there molecular AMR? |
|||
| IFTA NOS | Scarring? cause |
Is there molecular TCMR? Is there molecular AMR? How severe is the injury-repair response? |
[54] | |
| Other findings | Polyomavirus nephropathy | Molecular identification of BK virus Is there molecular TCMR? |
[56,57] | |
| Glomerulonephritis | Is there molecular AMR? |
AMR, antibody-mediated rejection; DSA, donor specific antibody; g, glomerulitis; MVI, microvascular inflammation; ptc, peritubular capillaritis; TCMR, T-cell mediated rejection; TMA, thrombotic microangiopathy; v, intimal arteritis.