Skip to main content
. 2022 Feb 10;95(1133):20211378. doi: 10.1259/bjr.20211378

Table 4.

Image quality comparison in the prospective test set with number of acquisitions = 1 (Median [Q1–Q3])

Accelerated Scan p-value
Qualitative metrics Reader DNN-N1pros TSE-N1pros TSE-Conv DNN-N1pros vs TSE-N1pros DNN-N1pros vs TSE-Conv
Overall image quality
1 5 [4–5] 3 [3–3] 4 [4–4] <0.001 <0.001
2 4 [4–5] 3 [2–3] 5 [5–5] <0.001 <0.001a
Perceived SNR
1 5 [5–5] 3 [3–3] 4 [4–4] <0.001 <0.001
2 5 [5–5] 3 [3–3] 5 [4–5] <0.001 <0.004
Artifacts
1 3 [2–4] 3 [2–4] 3 [3–4] 0.002b 0.825
2 4 [4–4] 4 [3–4] 4 [4–5] 0.102 <0.001a
Sharpness
Prostate 1 5 [4–5] 4 [3–4] 4 [4–5] <0.001 0.052
2 5 [4–5] 3 [3–4] 5 [5–5] <0.001 0.013
Seminal vesicle 1 5 [4–5] 4 [3–4] 5 [3–5] <0.001 0.272
2 5 [4–5] 3 [3–3] 5 [4–5] <0.001 0.366
Rectal wall 1 5 [4–5] 4 [3–4] 4 [4–5] <0.001 0.134
2 5 [4–5] 4 [3–4] 5 [5–5] <0.001 0.132
Urinary bladder 1 4 [4–5] 4 [4–4] 4 [4–4] <0.001 0.007
2 4 [4–5] 3 [3–4] 4 [4–5] <0.001 0.285
Obturator muscle 1 5 [5–5] 5 [4–5] 5 [5–5] <0.001 >0.999
2 5 [5–5] 4 [4–4] 5 [5–5] <0.001 0.025

N represents the number of acquisitions; DNN, a deep neural network; SNR, Signal-to-noise ratio; TSE, turbo spin echo images; TSE-Conv, turbo spin echo images from conventional scans;pros, the prospective test set was acquired with accelerated scans.

Bold numbers indicate statistically significant p-value with Bonferroni correction (p < 0.05/2).

a

indicates that DNN shows significantly lower values than TSE.

b

DNN-N1pros shows significantly higher artifact scores than TSE-N1pros (Averaged score: DNN-N1pros = 3.3 and TSE-N1pros = 2.8).