TABLE 3.
Year | Authors | Method/identified features | Dataset | Quality index | Quality index value |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
2013 | Tartar et al. 67 | Shape features | Dataset from Cerrahpasa Medicine Faculty, Istanbul University | Sensitivity | 0.896 |
Specificity | 0.875 | ||||
2014 | Teramoto et al. 107 | Shape features, intensity | Cancer‐screening program at the East Nagoya Imaging Diagnosis Center | Sensitivity | 0.83 |
2018 | Gong et al. 29 | Intensity, shape, texture features | LUNA16/ANODE09 | Sensitivity | 0.8462 |
2019 | Zuo et al. 108 | Multi‐resolution features integrated 2D CNN | LUNA16 | Accuracy | 0.9733 |
2019 | Zhou et al. 95 | 2/3D Models Genesis with encoder‐decoder architecture | LUNA16 | AUC | 0.982 |
2019 | Kim et al. 68 | Multi‐scale gradual integration CNN | LUNA16 | CPM | 0.942 |
2020 | Sun et al. 109 | S‐transform | Dataset from Sichuan Provincial People's Hospital | Sensitivity | 0.9787 |
2020 | Zuo et al. 69 | Multi‐branch 3D CNN | LUNA16 | CPM | 0.83 |
2020 | Masood et al. 70 | Multi‐PRN inspired by VGG‐16 | LUNA16/LIDC‐IDRI | Sensitivity | 0.974 |
2021 | Majidpourkhoei et al. 110 | CADe/CADx | LIDC‐IDRI | Accuracy | 0.901 |
Sensitivity | 0.841 | ||||
Specificity | 0.917 | ||||
2021 | Yuan et al. 71 | MP‐3D‐CNN | LUNA16 | CPM | 0.881 |
Sensitivity | 0.962 | ||||
2023 | Mkindu et al. 111 | 3D residual CNN with 3D ECA | LUNA16 | CPM | 0.911 |
Sensitivity | 0.9865 |
Abbreviations: AUC, area under the curve; CNN, convolutional neural network; CPM, competitive performance metrics.