Skip to main content
. 2024 Apr 6;12(7):795. doi: 10.3390/healthcare12070795

Table 3.

An example of clinical case which can have different treatment recommendations.

A Postmenopausal Woman Aged 52 Years, Undergoing Breast-Conserving Surgery for DCIS with the Following Features: Size 1.8 cm, Grade 2, 3 mm Negative Margins, no Comedonecrosis
According to the risk factors, she may be candidate for:
  • -

    Whole breast RT without boost according to ASTRO guidelines for Whole Breast RT [83]

  • -

    Whole breast RT with boost according to BIG 3-07/TROG 07.01 study [49]

  • -

    PBI according to ASTRO guidelines [50,79]

  • -

    RT omission according to RTOG 9804 study [21]

Decision-supporting tools:
  • -

    Van Nuys redefined score 7 [91] ->

LR risk 16% at 12 years
  • -

    Smith [156] 2/6 points ->

Moderate risk
  • -

    MSK nomogram [52]

With endocrine therapy 4% at 5 y;
7% at 10 y
Without endocrine therapy 9% at 5 y;
15% at 10 y
Additional parameters
Positive estrogen receptor status If endocrine therapy,
RT omission or PBI may be a viable option [112]
HER2 overexpression Whole breast RT may be a viable option,
RT is effective in reducing in situ recurrence [109]
High Ki67 (≥14) Whole breast RT may be a viable option,
RT is effective in reducing both in situ and invasive recurrence [104]
Highly needed additional tools
  • -

    Biosignature and genomic tests which can be used to tip the scales either in favour of RT omission or RT recommendation [13,23].


Oncotype DX gives an estimate of LR risk. The DCISionRT (PreludeDx) may also provide information for RT intensification.
In the setting of clinicopathologically low-risk DCIS, the DCISionRT reclassified 42% of patients into the Elevated-Risk Group [13], while 12-gene Oncotype DX reclassified about 10% of patients as a high-risk DS, which resulted in a 10-year risk of LR after BCS alone of more than 19% [168].
Biosignature and genomic tests may become greatly impactful in DCIS management once they are prospectively validated in randomized clinical trials.